COSEWIC assessment and status report on the Boreal Felt Lichen in Canada
Table of Contents
Assessment and Status Report
Boreal Felt Lichen
Atlantic population – Endangered
Boreal population – Special Concern
Committee on the Status
of Endangered Wildlife
Comité sur la situation
des espèces en péril
COSEWIC status reports are working documents used in assigning the status of wildlife species suspected of being at risk. This report may be cited as follows:
Please note: Persons wishing to cite data in the report should refer to the report (and cite the author(s)); persons wishing to cite the COSEWIC status will refer to the assessment (and cite COSEWIC). A production note will be provided if additional information on the status report history is required.
COSEWIC 2002. COSEWIC assessment and status report on the boreal felt lichen Erioderma pedicellatum in Canada. Committee on the Status of Endangered Wildlife in Canada. Ottawa. viii + 50 pp.
(Species at Risk Status Reports)
Maass, W. and D. Yetman. 2002. COSEWIC assessment and status report on the boreal felt lichen Erioderma pedicellatum in Canada, in COSEWIC assessment and status report on the boreal felt lichen Erioderma pedicellatum in Canada. Committee on the Status of Endangered Wildlife in Canada. Ottawa. 1- 50 pp.
For additional copies contact:
c/o Canadian Wildlife Service
Également disponible en français sous le titre Évaluation et Rapport de situation du COSEPAC sur la situation de l’erioderme boréal (Erioderma pedicellatum) au Canada
Boreal felt lichen -- Provided by the author, photo by Dr. C. Scheidegger
© Her Majesty the Queen in Right of Canada 2003
Catalogue No.: CW69-14/288-2003F-PDF
Boreal Felt Lichen
Boreal felt lichen (Erioderma pedicellatum) is a globally threatened, conspicuous foliose cyanolichen belonging to the Pannariaceae. It is the only boreal counterpart of a mainly tropical genus. The thallus is of a grayish brown colour when dry and a slate blue colour when moistened. It has a characteristic white underside, lacking a lower cortex. The curled to upturned lobes give it a unique appearance when viewed from a distance. New biochemical evidence suggests that the genus may be among the oldest of foliose lichens, hybridized from ancestral types, perhaps well over 400 million years ago (mya). Hybridization between an ancestral species and a mutant of it in South America likely gave rise to the boreal felt lichen. This new entity could have been transported on the microcontinent of West Avalonia to present day New England, New Brunswick, Nova Scotia and Newfoundland, and to the British Isles on the microcontinent of East Avalonia during Mid- to Late Ordovician (450-440 mya, departure time) and Devonian (360 mya or less, arrival time).
The species once had a global Amphi-Atlantic distribution with populations occurring in New Brunswick, Nova Scotia and Newfoundland in Eastern Canada and Sweden and Norway in Scandinavia. Currently the species is only known from Nova Scotia and Newfoundland.
Habitats of the boreal felt lichen may be referred to as the Suboceanic Lichen Forests of Atlantic Canada both because of the moist, Sphagnum-rich sites and because of the presence of a distinct cyanolichen community including E. pedicellatum. These suboceanic sites where Erioderma is found are generally on north or east-facing slopes that have a constant supply of moisture. Within these sites, the species is found mostly on balsam fir (Abies balsamea) and to a lesser extent on black spruce (Picea mariana) with rare occurrences on white spruce (Picea glauca), red maple (Acer rubrum) and white birch (cf. Betula cordifolia). On the coniferous trees mentioned, it can be found on both branches and trunks depending on the relationship between the level of moisture and light. It is known that this lichen shares an intimate relationship with the liverwort Frullania tamarisci ssp. asagrayana. The co-occurrence of Erioderma and Frullania is a visible external manifestation of the widespread internal symbiosis between Frullania and its cyanobacteria. Both Scytonema and Nostoc have been found to occur within the watersacs of Frullania. This intimate external symbiosis represents one of the delicate and complex relationships that this lichen shares with its ecosystem and for that reason its ecological balance is fragile and readily impacted by logging, air pollution and other factors.
Boreal felt lichen is a large foliose lichen with a generation time of about 30 years. It reproduces by sexual spores that are carried, likely, primarily by wind but also by other vectors such as flying insects and woodpeckers. No special asexual propagules are produced. One study has suggested that lichenization between the germinating ascospore and free-living Scytonema, a cyanobacterium (blue-green alga), can occur only in the water sacs of Frullania, a small, epiphytic, leafy liverwort. The relationship is such that the early synthesis of the lichen begins in the watersacs of Frullania wherein the free-living, cyanobacterial counterpart, Scytonema, is contained and comes into physical contact with Erioderma hyphae. Here under aseptic conditions the juvenile Erioderma thallus is formed and may take anywhere from 5-10 years to reach a visible size. Because of the presence of Scytonema, the lichen is particularly sensitive to acid rain, acid fog and other air pollutants. It requires relatively cool and moist oceanic climates within certain tolerances and open canopy for juvenile thalli to develop. Mature thalli deteriorate on trees that are mature to overmature or dead, seemingly in a span of only a few years. Thalli also deteriorate when habitat succession occurs that reduces light availability and when microclimatic conditions seem to be altered by extensive logging in close proximity to the lichen. Its occurrence on the particularly acidic bark of spruce trees reduces its ability, compared to fir trees, to survive when stressed by acidic air pollutants.
Population Sizes and Trends
Historically, E. pedicellatum occurred in Scandinavia but is now seemingly extirpated there. In considering all past and present confirmed occurrences, the range of the lichen in North America covers Campobello Island in New Brunswick, Cape Chignecto (alt. 136 m), the Atlantic slope of Nova Scotia at altitudes between 8 and 150 m, and the suboceanic parts of Newfoundland to an elevation of ~ 427 m. In Newfoundland, it is conspicuously absent from the eastern parts of the Great Northern Peninsula and from the northern central parts of the island. All of the 6 previously known localities for E. pedicellatum in southern Nova Scotia have been lost within the past 8-18 years. Environmental deterioration of the habitats through air pollution rather than through logging is the underlying cause for this change. Only 14 thalli are presently known to occur in Nova Scotia, as opposed to 169 thalli that had been encountered before 1995. In Newfoundland, about 6900 thalli of E. pedicellatum have been counted during the period after 1994, with about 35% of these having been documented in early 2002 by provincial foresters. The vast majority of the thalli were found on balsam fir with a much lower number on black spruce, the occasional thallus on white spruce, and a few on red maple and white birch. The total area of occupancy within which thalli have been documented in Newfoundland is about 30 km2 of habitat but likely consists of a much larger area when inaccessible areas along the south coast are included.
Limiting Factors and Threats
The species is in danger of population loss due to a number of threats. Perhaps the greatest threat is from logging, which is presently a major concern in Newfoundland. Clear-cutting is not conducive to the sustainability of Erioderma populations since clearcuts of 100 m x 100 m or more may act to desiccate local populations. This was historically the case in Vãrmland, Sweden, where logging in the immediate vicinity of the park where the Eriodermathalli occurred was the suspected cause of the eventual extirpation of this species. Other threats involve air pollution, forest pesticides, forest fires, climatic changes including global warming and moose herbivory on balsam fir seedlings.
Special Significance of the Species
Boreal felt lichen has served as a landmark species drawing attention to the need for lichen conservation. It is an ancient species whose fungal partner is believed to have evolved almost 500 mya. Its high susceptibility to air pollutants, perhaps more so than any other lichen species, makes it a prime candidate for monitoring changes in air quality.
Existing Protection or Other Status Designation
The species had originally been listed in 1995 as critically endangered in the “Red List of Lichenized Fungi of the World” by the Species Survival Commission (SSC) of the Lichen Specialist Group, International Union for the Conservation of Nature (IUCN).
No official status is recognized for Erioderma pedicellatum in any of the three Atlantic Provinces where it has occurred historically. Preliminary conservation measures had only been initiated in Newfoundland in response to recent suggestions by Dr. Christoph Scheidegger. Legal protection has existed for the large population in Jipujijkuei Kuespem Provincial Park as well as for populations in the Bay du Nord Wilderness Area and the Avalon Wilderness Area although these areas were not established specifically to protect this lichen. Interim protection was afforded, also, through an earlier promise made to Dr. Christoph Scheidegger and the ICCL in 1996, by then Premier Brian Tobin, that the Lockyer’s Waters Forest Area would not be harvested until the status of the boreal felt lichen had been determined by COSEWIC.
Summary of Status Report
Boreal felt lichen is a conspicuous foliose lichen that is found primarily on balsam fir in a very restricted type of cool moist suboceanic habitat. It is extirpated from its type location in New Brunswick where it was first reported in Canada. This species occurs now at only 3 sites with about 13 thalli in Nova Scotia and about 67 known sites on the island of Newfoundland. Only about 6900 extant thalli have been documented in total for the species in Canada. Of these, about 35% were discovered in Newfoundland in the spring of 2002 with renewed efforts to locate additional thalli. Considering that there are many forested riparian valley habitats with balsam fir in remote areas of the south coast of Newfoundland, it is highly likely that there are many more sites and numerous thalli yet to be discovered. Continued threats remain from the loss or modification of habitats through lumbering activities and from air pollutants.
For assessment purposes, the mainland populations in Nova Scotia and those of insular Newfoundland have been recognized as distinct COSEWIC populations due to the fact that they occur in different ecological regions and are subject to different degrees of risk, especially from atmospheric.
The Committee on the Status of Endangered Wildlife in Canada (COSEWIC) determines the national status of wild species, subspecies, varieties, and nationally significant populations that are considered to be at risk in Canada. Designations are made on all native species for the following taxonomic groups: mammals, birds, reptiles, amphibians, fish, lepidopterans, molluscs, vascular plants, lichens, and mosses.
COSEWIC comprises representatives from each provincial and territorial government wildlife agency, four federal agencies (Canadian Wildlife Service, Parks Canada Agency, Department of Fisheries and Oceans, and the Federal Biosystematic Partnership), three nonjurisdictional members and the co-chairs of the species specialist groups. The committee meets to consider status reports on candidate species.
- Any indigenous species, subspecies, variety, or geographically defined population of wild fauna and flora.
- Extinct (X)
- A species that no longer exists.
- Extirpated (XT)
- A species no longer existing in the wild in Canada, but occurring elsewhere.
- Endangered (E)
- A species facing imminent extirpation or extinction.
- Threatened (T)
- A species likely to become endangered if limiting factors are not reversed.
- Special Concern (SC)*
- A species of special concern because of characteristics that make it particularly sensitive to human activities or natural events.
- Not at Risk (NAR)**
- A species that has been evaluated and found to be not at risk.
- Data Deficient (DD)***
- A species for which there is insufficient scientific information to support status designation.
The Committee on the Status of Endangered Wildlife in Canada (COSEWIC) was created in 1977 as a result of a recommendation at the Federal-Provincial Wildlife Conference held in 1976. It arose from the need for a single, official, scientifically sound, national listing of wildlife species at risk. In 1978, COSEWIC designated its first species and produced its first list of Canadian species at risk. Species designated at meetings of the full committee are added to the list.
List of Figures
- Figure 1: A Large Healthy and Mature to Over-mature Thallus of Erioderma pedicellatum Photographed in the Lockyer’s Waters Forest Reserve by Dr. C. Scheidegger (x 5.7)
- Figure 2: The Chemical Structure of the Mixed Depsidone Eriodermin
- Figure 3: Overall Distributional Map for Occurrences of Erioderma pedicellatum on Balsam Fir (Abies balsamea) in Atlantic Canada, Based on Observations Made Both Before 1995 and After 1994
- Figure 4: Distributional Map for All of the Occurrences of Erioderma pedicellatum in Atlantic Canada that had been Known Prior to 1995
- Figure 5: Distributional Map for All of the Occurrences of Erioderma pedicellatum in Atlantic Canada that have been Based on Confirmed Observations Made After 1994
- Figure 6: Distributional Map for Occurrences of Erioderma pedicellatum on Spruce Trees in Atlantic Canada
- Figure 7: Newfoundland Vegetational Map and Erioderma pedicellatum Total Occurrences Plus May-Sept Precipitation Averages in mm
- Figure 8: Newfoundland Vegetational Map and Erioderma pedicellatum Total Occurrences Plus Average July Air Temperature in Degrees Centigrade
- Figure 9: pH Values Recorded for the Outer and Sub-surface Barks which had been Sampled from Trunks of Picea mariana During 1983 and 1984 in Nova Scotia and Processed as Well as Measured Under Standardized Conditions
- Figure 10: pH Values Recorded for the Outer and Sub-surface Barks which had been Sampled from the Trunks of Picea glauca during 1983 and 1984 in Nova Scotia and Processed as Well as Measured Under Standardized Conditions
- Figure 11: pH Values Recorded for the Outer and Sub-surface Barks which had been Sampled from the Trunks of Abies balsamea During 1983 and 1984 in Nova Scotia and Processed as Well as Measured Under Standardized Conditions
- Figure 12: The Water Retention Capacities for the Freshly Collected and Water Saturated Trunk Barks of Abies balsamea and Picea mariana Respectively
COSEWIC Status Report
Boreal Felt Lichen
It is not clear whether the generic name of the lichen was derived from the hairiness of the upper cortex or from the eriostratum of the underside (erion being the Greek name for wool and derma that for skin). Both features are highly characteristic of the genus.
In general, Erioderma is one of the most primitive genera of foliose lichens that may have originated in the Southern Hemisphere, on the Supercontinent of Gondwana (Jørgensen, 1990). It may have arrived in Laurentia (present day North America) on the microcontinent of West Avalonia, which had previously been in contact with the north-west coast of South America during the late Ordovician (Caradoc-Ashgile, 450-440 mya, see Figure 6, Benedetto et al., 1999). Its arrival in the British Isles is likely as a result of the previous contact of the microcontinent of East Avalonia with the Colombian Coast during the Late Ordovician (Arenigian, 490-480 mya, see Figure 5 in Benedetto et al. 1999). This hypothesis of the origin of the genus in the Southern Hemisphere is based on the hybrid chemistry of the lichen depsidone eriodermin (Connolly et al., 1984; Figure 2) found in Erioderma pedicellatum and several closely related species in South America and South Africa (Maass, 2003b). To confirm the hybrid nature of this species, it would be logical to search for and identify suitable fertile species that would have been able to donate the A and B rings present in eriodermin. These include species that contain either argopsin or pannarin or both as potential donors for ring A, i.e., E. groendahlianum (= E. polycarpum), E. leylandii ssp. azoricum, E. leylandii ssp. leylandii, E. leylandii ssp. velligerum (=E. chilense) and E. meiocarpum. Through the loss of genes in producing the β-orcinol substituents (via C-methylation or C-formylation), any of the above species could have generated a mutant producing the orcinol depsidone conwrightiin instead of the original β-orcinol depsidone. This mutant would have been a most suitable ring B donor for the metabolite eriodermin in hybrids formed through back-crossing with any of the above mentioned original species. The postulated mutant is one of the ancestors of today’s E. wrightii. The latter species contains one orcinol depside, i.e., wrightiin (Maass and Hanson, 1986) and one insufficiently characterized orcinol depsidone that accompanies the depside as a minor constituent and has therefore been named conwrightiin (Maass, unpublished). This minor constituent, characterized by its mass spectrum (in preparations extracted from lichens collected in Jamaica) was also encountered by Elix et al. (1986) in E. wrightii collected in Ecuador. Even the morphology of E. wrightii, with its concave apothecial disks (which appear to be present also in E. leylandii, according to the doctoral thesis by Ahlner 1948) makes the ancestor of this species a good candidate for having donated the genes for making the orcinol type of ring B in eriodermin.
Boreal felt lichen (Figure 1) is a foliose lichen that is usually between 2-5 cm in diameter but can attain a diameter of up to 12 cm. Smaller thalli have a relatively small holdfast area that is loosely attached to the substrate, most often to the mats of the hepatic Frullania tamarisci ssp. asagrayana rather than to the naked bark itself. On larger thalli, some of the radiating lobes are able to develop their own holdfasts. This may result in subdivision of the thallus.
The hairiness on the upper cortex of the lichen is clearly visible and is a characteristic feature of all species of Erioderma. The upturned margins reveal the whitish underside that is devoid of a lower cortex.
The thallus lobes are slightly involute, (i.e., curled upwards along their margins) exposing their whitish undersides. These appear felted by bundles of pale to darkish gray to bluish-gray branched hapteres (often discoloured) that form a dense eriostratum under optimal conditions. The hapteres have a dual function in anchoring the thallus to its substrate and taking up the nutrients from either stemflow or branchflow, whenever it rains. In the hydrated state the thallus has a bluish gray appearance due to the cyanobacterium, Scytonema. In the dry state its colour is dark gray to grayish brown.
The hairs on the upper surface of the thallus are commonly poorly developed but may be quite prominent in some specimens. In the generic key for the distinction between Erioderma, Leioderma and Parmeliella these hairs are described as being stiff and prominent (Galloway and Jørgensen 1987). Those in E. pedicellatum are often moderately branched, even in the centre of the thallus. Along the edges of the thallus they can form a semi-arachnoidal tomentum, whereas on older thalli this feature may be missing.
In cross-section, the lichen thallus is distinctly stratified. The upper cortex of the thallus consists of 2-4 layers of very thick-walled irregular colourless cells (30-50μ thick), with funnel-shaped gaps found to almost penetrate the cortical layer. The function of these intercellular spaces may be to promote the gas exchange required for photosynthesis and nitrogen fixation. Immediately below a narrow darkish transition zone of less than one cell layer thickness, the curled chains of the large-celled photobiont Scytonema are recognized. The algal layer is only between 45-90μ thick, in comparison with the well developed medulla in which the thickness varies between 200-600μ. A morphologically distinct lower cortex is absent. Thin-walled and branched septate rhizines can reach 1.5 mm in length.
Each thallus, after having reached at least 1.0 cm in diameter, develops an abundance of short-stalked apothecia up to 1.5 mm in diameter when reaching maturity. Mature thalli are usually at least 2-5 cm, and in rare cases, up to about 10 cm or more in diameter. Upon reaching this stage, young apothecia, whose margins are often fringed with whitish hairs, may be spotted along the growing edges of the thallus. More mature and varying developmental stages of apothecia will eventually be found scattered all over the upper surface, with up to nearly 100 per thallus. Whilst the apothecial stalk may be slightly compressed, the hymenial surfaces of the apothecia are initially flat but become conspicuously globose when mature. They are then dark brown and between 0.5-1.5 mm in diameter. Vegetative propagules in the form of either soredia or isidia are conspicuously absent in the life cycle.
Boreal felt lichen is distinguished chemically by the presence of a chlorinated depsidone called eriodermin (Figure 2; Maass, 1980). This constituent was first isolated in pure form from specimens of E. sorediatum D.J. Gall. & P.M. Jørg. (which is the sorediate counterpart of the fertile tropical species E. physcioides Vain). Eriodermin is an aromatic aldehyde in which the aldehyde group is in ortho position to a phenolic hydroxyl group, accounting for the PD+ (orange) reaction. Most other conventional colour test reagents give negative results (K-, C-, KC, I-).
Figure 2: The Chemical Structure of the Mixed Depsidone Eriodermin (which is the only secondary metabolite in Erioderma pedicellatum and related species of South and Central America, the Caribbean and/or Southeastern Africa)
Erioderma pedicellatum is an Amphi-Atlantic species that was historically present in Europe and in Canada. Currently, E. pedicellatum is only found in eastern Canada (Nova Scotia and Newfoundland).
In Norway, four localities were originally identified in the early 20th century. Alhner identified the lichen at three localities in the Grong region in 1938 and 1939 (Holien, 1995) and one locality in North Trondelag in 1948 (Maass, 1980b). Alhner believed that the species was new to science and gave it the name Erioderma boreale. More recently, two additional sites, in the Grong and Overhalla regions, were discovered in 1994 (Holien et al., 1995). Tor Tonsberg (pers. comm.) had confirmed in 1999 that one thallus remained from these recent discoveries; however, it is currently his opinion that the species has become extirpated in Norway.
In 1948, Ahlner discovered a site in Vãrmland, Sweden, consisting of 100+ thalli. This site was designated a nature reserve in 1952 (Holien, 1995). Holien states that the last reported sighting of thalli here was in 1956. Maass (1980) reported that Degelius (pers. comm.) had revisited the site and may have been the last to see it in 1962. Necrotic thalli from this last visit of his were deposited in various Swedish herbaria (GB, UPS). A colour photograph of bleached and corrosion-damaged thalli from this collection was included in the Fieldbook on Lichens by Moberg and Holmåsen (1982).
1) New Brunswick
J.G. Farlow made the earliest known collection of Erioderma pedicellatum in Canada on Campobello Island in 1902. This consisted of about 10 thalli. Farlow, realizing he had something unique, sent it to Hue for identification. Nine years later, Hue published it in an obscure journal under the name Pannaria pedicellata thereby reaching only a narrow audience. It is for this reason that a further sixty years would transpire before the original description of the species became known (Jørgensen 1972). To date, Stephen Clayden (1997), in his capacity as a curator at the New Brunswick Museum in St. John, NB, has, like the senior author, been unable to relocate or confirm the presence of E. pedicellatum on Campobello Island and in other parts of New Brunswick.
2) Nova Scotia
Most historic occurrences of E. pedicellatum in Nova Scotia were on the Atlantic Slope not more than 30 km from the coast in balsam fir (Abies balsamea) forests. The only exception was one dead thallus in the Cape Chignecto area above the Bay of Fundy on red maple (Acer rubrum) in site NS-46 (Maass, 1991). Further occurrences on phorophytes other than balsam fir include one thallus located in a white spruce (Picea glauca) grove about 100 m to the North of Toms Brook (NS-42) and one thallus (NS-6) on red maple. Most of the remaining occurrences had been in the northeastern parts of Halifax County and in Guysborough County. Only four (NS-42 to NS-45) had been located on Cape Breton Island, a considerable distance away from major centers of industrial activity such as Sydney and Glace Bay. All of the confirmed localities for E. pedicellatum are between 9 and 152 m above sea level. A total of 46 historic populations plus three sub-populations are known from this province.
Very limited lichenological exploration has been undertaken in Newfoundland. Ahti and Jørgensen first collected Erioderma pedicellatum in Newfoundland in 1971 under the synonym Erioderma boreale. Ten years would pass before additional attempts would be made to establish a distribution pattern for the species in Newfoundland (Maass 1980, Ahti 1983). Field crews of the Newfoundland Department of Forest Resources and Agrifoods made substantial contributions to Erioderma discoveries beginning in 1997. Altogether, about 67 principal localities have been listed for Newfoundland with almost as many sub-populations identified.
The total distributions of boreal felt lichen before 1995, after 1994, the total historic and current distribution and occurrences on balsam fir and on spruces are recorded in Figures 3-6.
Gaps in the distributional maps of this species in Newfoundland represent, for the most part, real disjunctions based on the presence of extensive areas of open heath habitat unsuitable for this species. In the southern coastal and central regions of Newfoundland, the potential still exists, however, of finding additional populations of the lichen in protected forested valleys within the extensive heath barrens. The pattern of distribution along the Atlantic coastline of Nova Scotia and in Newfoundland appear to be controlled by climatic factors such as those that characterize the oceanic boreal and hemi-boreal climatic zones representing cool, moist and often foggy conditions in the more coastal areas. The entire central northern portion of Newfoundland and the eastern region of the Great Northern Peninsula, although largely forested, appear to lie within climatic zones that are either too warm or too cold and/or too dry during the growing season (see Figures 7, 8).
Occurrences on red maple (Acer rubrum) have been indicated by a dotted triangular symbol and those on white spruce (Picea glauca) by an asterisk. In contrast, the occurrences of E. pedicellatum on black spruce have always been accompanied by occurrences of E. pedicellatum on balsam fir trees. The open circle on the coast of Maineindicates a possible former occurrence of the lichen, as explained in the legend for Figure 4.
Occurrences on red maple (Acer rubrum) have been indicated by a dotted triangular symbol and those on white spruce (Picea glauca) by an asterisk. - The type locality of E. pedicellatum has been highlighted by a circle around the dot. A possible former habitat of this species on Head Harbour Island SE of Jonesport in WashingtonCounty of the State of Maine, also, has been highlighted by an open circle. Herbarium specimens of both Coccocarpia palmicola and Lobaria scrobiculata are known to have been collected from balsam fir barks on this island (FH). These are the most characteristic habitat indicators for occurrences of E. pedicellatum on balsam fir trees.
On Picea mariana (represented by solid dots) and on Picea glauca (represented by an asterisk).
Black areas along the southwestern region near the coast are limestone heath. Localities occur primarily in regions with > 450 mm precipitation in the growing season.
Black areas along the southwestern region near the coast are limestone heath. Localities occur primarily in regions having temperatures below the July average of 16º C.
Generally, most habitats of Erioderma pedicellatum are found on northerly exposed slopes where cool and moist habitat conditions prevail, throughout much of the year. Under exceptional circumstances in Newfoundland, E. pedicellatum habitats are also found on or near the East-West running forested ridges of special geological formations (Ahti, 1983; Delaney and Cahill, 1977). Here too, there is acontinuous supply of moisture provided by the flow of cool air across the ridges, rising from adjacent valley wetlands to the South or Southwest. Such situations have been encountered, e.g., in the headlands of Hermitage Bay, on Ripple Pond Ridge and in Lockyer’s Waters. Because of the predominance of cyanophilic lichens, such as E. pedicellatum, in this wet variant of the Boreal Forest, the authors have named this unique habitat: The "Suboceanic Lichen Forest of Atlantic Canada".
In these suboceanic forest types, Erioderma pedicellatum is most commonly found on the trunks of balsam fir. In Newfoundland it also occurs on black spruce, although to a much lesser extent. Because the early stages in thallus development is photophilous (“light-loving”), the lichen is most often found on these trees at or near the bottom of slopes, where the habitat is open and, as well, adjacent to Sphagnum-rich wetlands. Sphagnum species are important in maintaining moisture levels in these forest habitats during periods of drought.
Erioderma pedicellatum is, in phytosociological terms, a species of the “Lobarion” a lichen association that contains, amongst many other epiphytic lichens, several species of Lobaria, most importantly L. scrobiculata. Since L. scrobiculata can be spotted from a distance, on account of its size and colour (brownish yellow in the dry state and bluish green in the wet state), it was a useful guide in the surveys conducted to study the distribution of E. pedicellatum in the boreal forests of Nova Scotia as well as those of Newfoundland (Maass 1983). It continues to be a good indicator for suitable microhabitats for E. pedicellatum on balsam fir. Other members of the Lobarion include Lobaria pulmonaria, L. quercizans and Pseudocyphellaria crocata, all of which commonly occur on a wide range of deciduous trees and shrubs and even on conifers. Whereas these species may often be found in abundance on spruces (along with Lobaria scrobiculata) in nutrient-rich forested slopes and flood-plain habitats, they are only exceptionally present on balsam fir, which is the principal phorophyte for Erioderma pedicellatum.
The mature forest habitat in which Erioderma pedicellatum is found is characterized by distinct herbaceous flowering plants and cryptogam species. The herb layer is characterized by the presence of such species as: Clintonia borealis, Coptis trifolia, Cornus canadensis, Gaultheria hispidula and most importantly by the moisture dependent Osmunda cinnamomea. In half-open alluvial woods the latter may be replaced by Onoclea sensibilis. Sphagnum mosses include S. girgensohnii,S. fallax, S. nemoreum and/or S. russowii. Other bryophytes that predominate include the hepatic Bazzania trilobata, the pleurocarpous mosses Hylocomium splendens, Pleurozium schreberi, Ptilidium crista-castrensis and Rhytidiadelphus triquetrus and the acrocarpous mosses Dicranum majus and D. scoparium. The crowns of the trees are typically covered by a very lush growth of beard lichens, including Usnea longissima, Alectoria sarmentosa and Bryoria trichodes ssp. trichodes. The presence of these beard lichens in the canopy of the forest can act as a moisture buffer to maintain high humidity conditions.
It is assumed that the limit of distribution for Erioderma pedicellatum is reached where the climatic conditions are not sufficiently cool and humid to maintain a constant supply of moisture during the warmer and drier parts of the year. The northernmost locality where E. pedicellatum had been sighted on black spruce (Picea mariana) is in the northernmost section of the Burgeo Road (just below lat. 48º30'N; see Figure 6). The northernmost limit of the known distribution of E. pedicellatum is reached on the western side of the Northern Peninsula of Newfoundland just north of Hawkes Bay (lat. 50º43') (Figure 3).
Regardless of the distributional limits of this species, certain generalized statements can be made regarding its ecological requirements. In well-lit forests, E. pedicellatum is found mostly on trunks, in contrast to shaded habitats where the species is found predominately on branches. An important ecological balance may explain the preference of trunks or branches namely in those niches where the requirements for light are being balanced against those for uninterrupted conditions of high humidity. It is possible that in Nova Scotia the humidity levels in suitable woodland habitats for Erioderma have been too discontinuous during the warmest parts of the year to allow the branches to be colonized, even those on Abies. Only two exceptional thalli had been encountered on branches within the lowlands of Richmond County in southeastern Cape Breton Island (localities NS-42 and NS-43).
Symbiosis with Frullania
The hepatic Frullania tamarisci ssp. asagrayana plays a central role in helping Erioderma pedicellatum become established on the trunks of suitable conifers (Maass, 1986). Frullania species are distinguished by the possession of more or less helmet-shaped involutions on the underside of the dorsal leaves. These water sacs are important for a prolonged supply of moisture, and contain growth inhibitors, bacteriostatic compounds and insect-feeding deterrents (Burnett et al., 1974; Asakawa et al., 1976). Within these aseptic watersacs it is believed the process of lichenization begins in such a way that the E. pedicellatum fungus genetically recognizes the free-living Scytonema. Subsequent to lichenization, Frullania provides suitable nursery beds for the establishment and growth of the juvenile stages of E. pedicellatum, which would otherwise be difficult on the naked barks of phorophytes. In exceptional cases in which Erioderma pedicellatum has been found on red maple, this function may be performed also by Frullania bolanderi or F. oakesiana.
Conversely, Frullania may benefit from the products of nitrogen fixation supplied by the newly formed thalli of cyanophilic lichens and by the still free-living cyanobiont cells within the watersacs. Frullania may even benefit from certain metabolites of the lichen fungi being released, such as growth hormones (IAA, gibberellic acids). Even the secretion of some polyketide-derived aromatic lichen acids might be of some use to Frullania.
Dr. Tomas Hallingbäck observed, in the forests of southern Sweden some years ago, that leafy hepatics like Frullania, Porella, Ptilidium pulcherrimum and Radula are good micro-environmental substrates for cyanobacteria (unpublished data). He also placed emphasis on his findings that some epiphytic mosses can likewise serve as a good microenvironment for cyanobacteria. Leucodon sciuroides was quoted as having the highest concentration of Nostoc species (pers. com.). Leucodon brachypus var. andrewsianus has been reported as Leucodon sciuroides in Erioderma habitats in Newfoundland (Crum and Anderson, 1981).
Brief Note on Bark Acidities
The acidities (Figures 9-11) and buffering capacities of the barks of the lichen phorophytes play a key role in accommodating or rejecting nitrogen-fixing lichen epiphytes on account of their high sensitivity to air pollution. The effect of bark acidity on the colonization of Lobarion lichens had been observed in the wet forest habitat of the Musquodoboit River Valley adjacent to the Limestone Quarries at Upper Musquodoboit (Maass 1983). Here, in an inland area where Lobaria scrobiculata does not normally occur on this substrate, the fir trunks had become literally covered by this lichen due to the neutralizing effects of limestone on the bark. However, more astonishing was the fact that black spruce trees in the same habitat had not been colonized at all, in spite of the neutralizing effects of the limestone. Higher bark pH (Figure 11), together with the greater water retention capacity of balsam fir bark (Figure 12), could explain why this species is the preferred phorophyte for Erioderma pedicellatum, both in Nova Scotia and in Newfoundland. This same phenomenon on spruce was also observed in Oslo, Norway, in the Ostmarka Forest Reserve (Gauslaa, 1995; Holien, 1982).
Numerous samples of Frullania were collected from Upper Musquodoboit, on both black spruce and balsam fir for sectioning and microscopic examination of the contents of their water sacs. No evidence was found for the presence of cyanobacteria in the Frullania samples from spruce, whereas more often than not the healthy random samples of Frullania from firs contained cyanobacterial cells.
The boundaries of Jipujijkuei Kuespem Provincial Park were amended in 1997 to allocate a 213 ha portion to the Conne River Mi’gmaw Band to operate a private campground. Development is possible in this area; however, any proposal has to go through the provincial regulatory review process. The remaining 669 ha are still under the jurisdiction of the provincial government and protected under the Provincial Park Act. Much of the Erioderma population occurs within the new park boundaries.
Figure 9: pH Values Recorded for the Outer and Sub-surface Barks which had been Sampled from Trunks of Picea mariana During 1983 and 1984 in Nova Scotia and Processed as well as Measured Under Standardized Conditions
The scale of pH values has been plotted on the x axis, whereas the numbers of equivalent measurements obtained above the baseline are being shown on their respective coordinates parallel to the y axis.
Note that the actual numbers of measurements correspond to n+1 (as far as measurements have been plotted on the baseline).
Figure 10: pH Values Recorded for the Outer and Sub-surface Barks which had been Sampled from the Trunks of Picea glauca During 1983 and 1984 in Nova Scotia and Processed as well as Measured Under Standardized Conditions
The frequencies for the occcurrence of Coccocarpia palmicola (x) and Lobaria scrobiculata (o) on the tree barks sampled have been indicated by the symbols shown in brackets.
Note that the actual numbers of measurements correspond to n+1 (as far as measurements have been plotted on the base line).
Figure 11: pH Values Recorded for the Outer and Sub-surface Barks which had been Sampled from the Trunks of Abies balsamea During 1983 and 1984 in Nova Scotia and Processed as well as Measured Under Standardized Conditions
The frequencies for the occurrence of Coccocarpia palmicola (x) and Lobaria scrobiculata (o) on the tree barks sampled have been indicated by the symbols shown in brackets.
Note that the actual numbers of measurements correspond to n+1 (as far as measurements have been plotted on the baseline).
The measurements plotted have been based on barks sampled in the former Erioderma habitat between Clam Harbour and Owls Head Harbour. The respective trees had been very healthy and had been growing under comparable conditions. Their DBH had been comparable at about 15 cm.
The life cycle of E. pedicellatum is still incompletely known and will remain so until the life cycle of its photobiont Scytonema has been studied in detail. The distribution and micro-ecology of this cyanobacterium within the forests containing E. pedicellatum are presently insufficiently known. Even the vectors for the distribution of the spores of E. pedicellatum have not been fully recognized; however, the junior author has investigated flying insects as potential vectors of Erioderma spores in a Masters thesis currently under completion. For most components of the life cycle, only hypothetical considerations can be given.
Only sexual reproduction is known for E. pedicellatum. Therefore the lack of vegetative propagules makes E. pedicellatum dependent upon a de novo synthesis of new thalli. This means that initiation of a new life cycle is a chance encounter between the more or less full complement of eight spores from a single ascus and a suitable strand of the free-living form of the cyanobacterium, Scytonema. The process of lichenization then begins. Such chance encounters would have a much greater probability of being successful if both the spores and the photobiont partners were to find refuge in a microbiologically suitable microenvironment, such as in the watersacs of Frullania (Scheidegger, 1996).
Most recently Yetman (unpublished data from Masters thesis) has shown that the spores of E. pedicellatum are ejected either individually or as groups of 8 per ascus. This has been confirmed using scanning electron micrograph imaging. Based on recent laboratory experiments, it is likely the spores are ejected under suitable weather conditions, usually after a dry weather period when the humidity of the air goes up and fog is rolling in or when the first drops of rain are falling.
Favoured by the frequent incidence of fog or rain, by the favourable characteristics of the lichen forest's understory and tree canopy, as well as by the availability of adjacent wetlands, it may be assumed that the primary spore dispersal mechanism of E. pedicellatum is operative during most if not all parts of the year. Exceptions to this rule may be imposed by the few weeks of hot weather during the summer and during snowy and frosty periods in the winter. Studies on Xanthoria parietina in the British Isles and Oregon have shown that viable spores of this species can be obtained throughout the year (Christmas 1980). On the other hand, there are lichens such as Rhizocarpon lecanorinum, that show a peak performance in the spore dispersal during a specific time of the year (Clayden 1997b). So far, according to the junior author (unpublished data for Masters thesis) it seems that at least E. pedicellatum does not disperse over the hot, dry months of summer.
The following vectors may assist in spore dispersal of E. pedicellatum to adjacent or more distant suitable habitats:
- Strong moisture-laden winds that will carry the released spores up to a few hundred metres into an adjacent younger woodland (Scheidegger, 1996). The prevailing windstorms on the Avalon Peninsula blow either from East to West (during the winter months) or in the opposite direction from Southwest to Northeast (during the summer months). Analogous prevailing wind directions have also been recorded for Cape Breton Island, according to data from the Point Aconi Weather Station (see Maass and Richardson 1994). On the mainland of Nova Scotia, e.g., in Halifax County, the winds often come directly from the North (during the winter) or from the South (in the summer and during the hurricane season). The presence of variable and moderate winds in these semi-closed canopy forests would undoubtedly carry spores to adjacent younger balsam fir stands.
- Insects as possible dispersal agents. Through a series of studies it was shown that insects could be dispersal agents of Erioderma spores (unpublished data for Masters thesis by Yetman). Initially in laboratory experiments, fruit fly (Drosophila melanogaster) larvae were allowed to mature and roam for 48 hours in an experimental chamber containing a mature Erioderma thallus. Following this, the fruit flies were anaesthetized and viewed under a scanning electron microscope. Erioderma spores were positively identified, adhered to the leg bristles of several fruit flies. These findings were reconfirmed in the field in the summer of 2001 in mature forest stands in Lockyer’s Waters, Newfoundland. Erioderma spores were identified on the segmented antennae of Anapsis rubis, a small flying beetle, using SEM. It is probable that such flying insects disperse viable spores to far reaching forest stands; this may result in the creation of a thallus but only if at least two spores remain adhered in a clump while landing on a Frullania to germinate and make contact with a suitable Scytonema symbiont in the water sacs of this hepatic. Although spores of E. pedicellatum also adhere to the legs of mosquitoes, no proof has yet been obtained as to how far these insects can travel (Yetman, unpublished data). We suspect that mosquitoes do not get air-borne during windstorms.
- Birds. Woodpeckers, and possibly other birds, are an additional potential vector for the long distance dispersal of viable spores of E. pedicellatum from over-mature balsam firs. Spores could be picked up involuntarily on their front and/or tail feathers while the birds forage for bark-inhabiting insect larvae immediately following a brief dry weather period when most of the ripened spores are normally ejected.
Scheidegger (1996) states the following concerning the life cycle of Erioderma pedicellatum. [The following life cycle scenario has not been conclusively demonstrated.]
- Only one generation of Erioderma occurs during one successional cycle of the so-called lichen forest.
- During the approximately 15 to 25 years of the over-mature to decaying phase of the forest, previously established thalli of E. pedicellatum are able to achieve a high growth rate due to favourable light conditions. The reproductive phase of the lichen is restricted to this period when microscopically small diaspores are dispersed [each spore measuring about 4-6 μm in length, Yetman, unpublished] through hypothetical vectors to a considerably younger tree, possibly in an adjacent stand corresponding to an earlier successional stage of the fir-dominated coniferous forest.
- The life cycle of Erioderma would therefore begin again in another stand of suitable ecology and successional stage, at a distance of up to a few hundred meters from the original population. The capture of a suitable cyanobacterium (Scytonema) would lead to the development of minute individuals by a process that could last for more than ten years, whilst the stand might be reaching its optimal phase of growth.
Scheidegger's life cycle model has validity in as far as it applies to those forests that have adjacent blocks of even-aged trees at different developmental stages. Such a model would then apply to stands selectively cut during the past two hundred years, such as the forests in Lockyer’s Waters, Newfoundland. The same might be accomplished by epidemic outbreaks of forest pests and forest fires. The “wave forests” on the West Coast of the Great Northern Peninsula of Newfoundland also show alternating strips of synchronized tree growth. The same applies to the wave forests on St. Paul’s Island and those in the most north-easterly region of Cape Breton, although the wind velocities in most of these highly exposed habitats are too forbidding for the establishment of a new generation of thalli.
Young regenerating forest stands within which new life cycles of E. pedicellatum are initiated have rarely been encountered. The only possible exception is site NF-21b in Jipujijkuei Kuespem Park where a fairly large juvenile population of E. pedicellatum has been discovered (Yetman, 1999). The earliest stages in the colonization of a synchronized young woodland site by E. pedicellatum have so far remained undetected.
Scheidegger's scenario of the amount of available light becoming increasingly greater during the life cycle of Erioderma may not be totally inclusive. The presence of adult thalli in half-open very hydric habitats appears to support the claim that the de novo re-synthesis of thalli of E. pedicellatum requires a fair amount of light. Older well-established thalli of E. pedicellatum are probably quite adaptable to changes in the light intensity as long as sufficiently high levels of humidity are supplied. Such changes in the light intensity might be caused by opening or closing of the canopy, by the death of individual trees adjacent to the phorophyte, or by the maturation of younger trees in the understory beneath the canopy of the forest.
Concerning the life cycle of Erioderma pedicellatum, it seems more relevant to conclude that as relatively young and small natural stands of balsam fir continue to grow, the amounts of light available to the lichen (or its free living photobiont) might either increase or decrease to the point below which E. pedicellatum and Scytonema containing Frullania can survive depending on the stability of the moisture regime. Such occasional habitats are encountered in high humidity areas of Newfoundland (sites NF-2 and NF-25) where E. pedicellatum thalli have remained exclusively confined to the branches.
Nevertheless, based on numerous field observations it is important to maintain either a mosaic of forest stand age classes adjacent to one another or multi-age stands.
Growth rates of mature thalli, in the exponential phase of growth, are somewhat comparable on balsam fir and spruce. The highest annual growth rates had been observed on balsam fir, with growth index (g.i.) values of up to 13 and 14 mm/yr on branches and trunks respectively (thallus # 2-b on balsam fir, # 2 at Salmonier Nature Park (SALM); thallus # 2-t on balsam fir, # 13 at Fitzgerald Pond Park (FITZ)). The largest g.i. value on black spruce was recorded for thallus # 3-b on tree # 4 at SALM, i.e., 11 mm/yr. This was in spite of the fact that the thallus had become strongly necrotic above its holdfast area during the growth period of a little over 11 months between subsequent measurements.
The growth rate measurements on balsam fir had also included two immature thalli. One of them (thallus # 2-t on tree # 8) had been encountered at FITZ and the other one (thallus # 1-t on tree # 3) at Goobies, NF. The initial measurements, taken on two consecutive days in October of 1980, had been the same for both thalli, namely 6 x 4 mm/yr. The subsequent annual growth increments had been 3 x 4 mm/yr at FITZ and 3 x 2 mm/yr at Goobies, NF. In addition, a juvenile thallus had been studied on spruce at SALM (thallus # 2-b on tree # 3). During the 11-month period between 2 Oct.1980 and 7 Sept.1981 it had increased its growth in length and width by about 50% (12 mm= x 10 mm per yr). This is similar to growth rates measured for young thalli on balsam fir during a comparable time interval.
Population Numbers, Sizes and Trends
- New Brunswick
- Nova Scotia
- Population Trends on Black Spruce
- A Note on the Misinterpretation of “Numbers”
The numbers of thalli of E. pedicellatum in the Maritime Provinces and insular Newfoundland have been summarized for the periods before 1995 and after 1994 and are provided below
Only about 10 thalli were documented in 1902 from the original collection locality on Campobello Island. No thalli have been found at the type locality since the original occurrence of this species in New Brunswick became more widely known through the publication by Jørgensen (1972).
The total number of thalli counted before 1995 in Nova Scotia had been 169. Of these, two had been found on the trunks of red maple, one on the fairly thick branch of a white spruce and one on a thin branch of balsam fir. The remaining 165 thalli occurred on the trunks of 102 balsam firs. The average number of thalli per trunk of balsam fir was therefore approximately 1.6. The total number of thalli that could be located in Nova Scotia in the late 90s was only 13, amounting to a reduction in numbers by about 92%. Accordingly, the total number of balsam fir trees colonized had shrunk from 102 to 7. It had been hoped that the habitat in the Moser River Valley (loc. NS-27) would have had the potential of maintaining itself for another ten or more years, since the present thallus to tree ratio was close to 2 per tree and since the habitat was relatively sheltered against receiving pollutants from the road. In spite of the high humidity at the site, caused by moisture rising from the adjacent swampy and wooded bottom of the river valley, the entire population had collapsed by the end of September 2002.
Within only a couple of years after 1979, when the senior author had begun to search for the presence of E. pedicellatum in all accessible suitable habitats of Nova Scotia, the lichen had disappeared from the southern parts of the province, even though the respective habitats had remained intact upon superficial inspection. Of the 46 localities originally found in Nova Scotia, only 3 localities (NS-12, NS-16 and NS-27, all in the eastern sub-coastal parts of Halifax County) have retained a viable habitat. Degraded habitats include all of those that had originally contained between 9 and 20 thalli.
Only 2 thalli had been encountered on branches, both of these in the most humid parts of the lowlands of Cape Breton Island. One had occurred on balsam fir near Enon (in loc. NS-43) and one on a white spruce in a very moist valley habitat (loc. NS-42). Two other exceptional occurrences had been on the trunks of red maple (locs. NS-6 and NS-46).
The population counts for the Island of Newfoundland are summarized below. Supplementary data compiled by provincial foresters based on fieldwork conducted in early 2002 subsequent to the completion of this report are now also included in this final draft. [This supplementary information of thalli counts was provided to COSEWIC members by the range jurisdiction representatives during discussions on status designation.]
Areas and Significant Populations
Occurrences of Erioderma pedicellatum have been documented in the following geographical areas of Newfoundland (in progressive order from Northwest to Southeast).
Area 1: GreatNorthern Peninsula (western slope)
A total of 23 thalli were recorded before 1995 and only 3 after 1994, all on balsam fir.
Area 2: Burgeo Road (northern areas)
Only 22 thalli have been documented on balsam fir and 1 thallus on black spruce between the Trans Canada Highway and Peter Strides Pond, all before 1995.
Area 3: Burgeo Road (Headlands of Grandy Brook)
Boreal felt lichen was only recorded after 1994 in this area; 88 thalli were found on balsam fir.
Area 4: South Central Newfoundland
This area includes regions between Great Burnt Lake, the Twin Brooks area to the Northwest of Hwy. 362, Jipujijkuei Kuespem Park, Hermitage Bay and Belle Bay areas (280 thalli on balsam fir, 199 on black spruce and 4 on red maple, for a total of 483 before 1995; 2671 thalli on balsam fir and 5 on black spruce for a total of 2675 found after 1994. [Additional surveys by provincial foresters on 13th and 14th of March 2002 in Jipujijkuei Kuespem Park added 1068 more thalli (1065 on balsam fir and 3 on white birch). Also, new surveys on 12th and 15th March, 2002 added 746 new thalli to the Salt Pit-Twin Brooks area, all found on balsam fir (pers. com. to Natalie Djan-Chekar from Bill Clarke, Forestry & Wildlife, 25 Apr. 2002). This totals about 4489 thalli in this region found after 1994.]
Salt Pit - Twin Brooks Road Population
The habitat for this population is about 3-4 km inland from Head of Bay D’Espoir and within about 1 km to the Northwest from Hwy. 361. The population number of 518 thalli is based on counts made by members of Newfoundland and Labrador Department of Forest Resources and Agrifoods (NFS). This area is not likely to receive protection of any kind, since intensive logging operations are being carried out in the general area on a continuing basis. The six sub-sites occupy an area of about 2 km2. Some of the studies by Robertson (1998) have highlighted wave forests where well-illuminated niches are created that may or may not become subsequently colonized by E. pedicellatum
Jipujijkuei Kuespem Park Population
The total number of E. pedicellatum thalli encountered within the former boundaries of the Park on balsam fir is 2107, and the approximate number of trees colonized is ~1088, which corresponds to a ratio of about 2 thalli / tree. The potential E. pedicellatum habitats in the Park cover an area up to 4 000 000 m2. So far, 13 more or less discrete sub-sites with a minimum of 30 thalli in each have been studied, which includes all areas on both sides of the River Pond. The most recent survey is that by Yetman (1999) who discovered a relatively juvenile habitat of 201 thalli on balsam fir in a former gravel pit that may have been used for the construction of Hwy. 360. The respective sub-site (NF-21b) contained 57 % juveniles. In general out of the 1021 thalli found here, 33.1% (338) are juvenile. This is an exceptionally high percentage compared to other populations in Newfoundland. The survival rate of these 338 immature thalli to spore-bearing maturity cannot be determined. However, the importance of their presence is that they attest to the healthy condition of the free-living forms of the Scytonema in these forests during those years when the immature thalli had been formed. Obviously, the creation of these juveniles demanded relatively pollution-free conditions.
There is a mix of serious and relatively minor threats in the Park, when considering other areas in Newfoundland. Moose browsing does occur in the Park but has not become as serious a factor as in Lockyer’s Waters. In contrast, however, aerial spraying of pesticides can be harmful to E. pedicellatum and has in the past been considered for this area.
Area 5: Burin Peninsula
This includes the peninsula and nearby islands in the Placentia Bay; 12 thalli were recorded on balsam fir and 1 thallus on the trunk of a white spruce before 1995 and 11 thalli after 1994, without specific information on substrates.
Area 6: East Central Newfoundland
This is the pond-rich sub-oceanic Bay-du-Nord Wilderness area that had not been visited before 1995, and the areas between Glovertown and Come-By-Chance; 125 thalli were recorded on balsam fir, mostly near Goobies, before 1995 and 128 thalli, all in the Bay-du-Nord lake district, after 1994.
Bay-du-Nord Wilderness Reserve Population
Habitats are located about 58 - 63 km to the West of Clarenville and North East of Meta Pond. They are distributed over 6 sites that contain altogether 16 sub-sites. The total number of thalli recorded for this Reserve was 128. The total area within which these newly found populations of E. pedicellatum were encountered lies within an area approximately 28.25 km2. Of the nearly 30 km2 mentioned, much of the land is occupied by heath-lands and rocky barrens, thereby giving a more approximate estimation of less than 15 km2. Based on this type of calculation for habitat size and considering our preliminary knowledge of this area, it remains a matter of uncertainty whether the Bay-Du-Nord Wilderness area should be considered as one of the major habitats or whether it is not better treated as a large area with numerous meta-populations.
Area 7: Avalon Peninsula
Lockyer’s Waters Population
The total count of thalli in the Lockyer’s Waters by the end of 1997 had surpassed 900; these had been found on close to 500 balsam fir trees, within 10 subsites (McHugh, 1998). This count has recently been adjusted to 953 (Yetman, 1999). The average ratio of thalli of E. pedicellatum on the occupied trees in the Lockyer’s Waters was close to 2:1.
Nine well-established and distinctly different sub-populations with respect to exposure, stand age and canopy density are present (McHugh, 1998). These sites cover an area of about 20 hectares whilst the trees themselves bearing Erioderma would cover only 5.54 hectares. Important long-term research in these areas is presently being conducted in order to learn more about the life cycle of Erioderma and the impact of environmental stress.
A number of factors currently threaten the population. First, the remote area to the southeast of Lockyer’s Waters is surrounded by cottage country (with over 1500 cottages). Second, the high density of moose in the area has stunted the regrowth of suitable stands of balsam fir for recolonization by second-generation Erioderma thalli. Third, during windstorms from a southwesterly direction, pollutants from the industrial areas of Holyrood may reach the wooded hills of Lockyer’s Waters and affect some of the populations of the lichen on northwesterly exposed slopes. And finally, the threat of logging in the area is still of concern. In 1997, logging was halted pending status designation for Erioderma pedicellatum by COSEWIC. Despite this interim protective measure, the future use of Lockyer’s Waters forests has not been determined.
Ripple Pond Ridge Road Population
Ripple Pond Ridge Road, which was built in 1997 for the purpose of salvaging wind-fallen timber, is about 3.5 km long and contains some very steep sections. The E. pedicellatum sites recorded (NF-80x to NF-80e) are discontinuously distributed along the length of this road, the great majority of them are within only a 50 m distance from the road. For an estimation of the area covered by these sub-populations, a 200 m broad strip of land was chosen as the basis for the following calculation: 3 500 m x 200 m = 700 000. A total of about 350 thalli had been present originally, including 18 thalli on black spruce. This is or was the second largest habitat for occurrences of E. pedicellatum on black spruce during the period after 1994. It is uncertain what impact logging operations will have on the long-term survival of this population.
Ripple Pond Population
Two sub-populations (NF-79a and NF-79b) were found in the woodlands about 300-350 m behind the western shores of Ripple Pond, more exactly 150-200 m to the Southwest and Northeast of a small pond which is located about halfway between the Ripple Pond and a narrow strip of sloping peatland to the West. The sub-populations are about 600 m apart from one another and contain a total of 154 thalli. The habitats for E. pedicellatum cover areas up to 300 000 m2 (= 0.3 km2).
Ninth Fox Pond Population
The two sub-sites combined contain 95 thalli on 70 trees of balsam fir and 39 thalli on the branches of 9 trees of black spruce. The area covered by the two sub-sites is about 100 000 m2. In the lower part of sub-site NF-80w some manual thinning had been carried out that might provide a future experimental research site.
Noseworthy’s Gully Population
Behind the East side of Noseworthy’s Gully or Pond lies site NF-81b. It consists of an interesting mosaic of fens and forest habitats on a mix of level ground and slopes (Ringius 1997; Robertson 1998). Here, 122 thalli of E. pedicellatum have been seen on an estimated number of 65 trees of balsam fir in one locality, and a few thalli on several trees of black spruce. The habitats encompass a total area of about 200 x 200 m (4 ha).
As a matter of curiosity, a few thalli have been found much farther to the north at Pegs Pond on the Carbonear Line (loc. NF-84).
The total count of thalli seen or recorded on the Avalon Peninsula during the past 3-4 years is 2148 (i.e., 2085 on balsam fir and 63 on black spruce), whereas before 1995 it was 107 thalli (19 on black spruce). This difference reflects the intensified search for this lichen in the woodlands of Newfoundland since 1996.
A revised total count for Newfoundland, including discoveries in March 2002, amounts to just under 6900 extant thalli. With many suitable habitats remaining in unexplored remote areas of the southern coast of insular Newfoundland, it is anticipated that there may be many more extant thalli.
Comparing Newfoundland’s Two Largest Populations
A comparison between the two largest populations of E. pedicellatum in Newfoundland sheds some light on the chances for long-term survival of the species. The largest and healthiest population occurs within Jipujijkuei Kuespem Park. The Park, excluding small adjacent populations to the North and East, has a total of 2112 thalli (including 5 morbid thalli on black spruce). When considering only populations of thalli in which distinctions were made between adult and juvenile thalli, the percentage of juveniles is 31.75% (327:1030 = x100). Perhaps anomalous to the trend was the high percentage of juveniles (57%) encountered by Yetman (1999) in subsite NF-21b. [NFS new records for this park found on 13th and 15th March, 2002 total 1068 thalli (pers. com. Newfoundland Forest Service)]
In comparison, the populations in Lockyer’s Waters consist of 952 thalli on balsam fir and 1 dead thallus on black spruce. According to data provided by McHugh (1998), 165 juveniles and 698 mature thalli had been documented in “sites 1 to 9”. Upon applying the same ratio to the updated figure for thalli found on balsam fir (952), the total number of juveniles in Lockyer’s Waters may be close to 182.
The Jipujijkuei Kuespem Park contains more than twice the number of thalli on balsam fir (2107) as compared to those that are present in Lockyer’s Waters on the same substrate (952). Approximately 31.75 % of those in the Jipujijkuei are juveniles, which translates into 669 young thalli, on the basis of extrapolations. This means that there are ~3.7 times more young thalli in the Jipujijkuei Kuespem Park than in Lockyer’s Waters. This figure, in the absence of mortality, reflects the possibility of long-term survival of the species in Jipujijkuei Kuespem Park.
Because of the heightened air pollution sensitivity of the lichen on this substrate the health and long-term persistence of thalli on spruces is in question (see Limiting Factors).
In former times, under largely pollution-free conditions, black spruce trees served as much better substrates for colonization by E. pedicellatum than presently. In the early 1980s, the average size of the colonies of E. pedicellatum on individual black spruces was nearly 4 times greater than the colonies on individual balsam fir trees. For instance, at least 50 healthy thalli had been observed on a single spruce in sub-site NF-27a of which 40% had been juveniles. The largest number of thalli observed on the trunk of a single balsam fir had been 16 (in site NF-15). Before 1995, 28.3% of the thalli found were on black spruce, whereas after 1994, only 1.5% of the thalli occurred on the same substrate.
The occurrences of E. pedicellatum on the black spruces of Newfoundland is therefore a good monitoring system to forecast problems in the environment that may become a threat to the long-term survival of the species as a whole, especially regarding air pollution. It is particularly important to maintain records on the health status of E. pedicellatum on this particular substrate.
There is a misconception as population numbers grow, as with E. pedicellatum, that the species is well distributed, essentially “everywhere”. It is appropriate, however; to take a more cautious approach in assessing the present situation. Thallus counts, as with all population assessments, are by no means static entities. This is particularly true when data are accumulated over a short period of time (1996-1999). This scenario becomes more complicated when populations are not distinct and therefore sub and meta-populations exist. For example, localities in Nova Scotia with meta-populations containing up to 20 thalli have been lost within only ten years. True to the nature of meta-population biology, such isolated and therefore vulnerable minor occurrences hold little hope for the long-term survival of the species.
Aside from that, no one can control and maintain the well-being of small populations, even with the best of intentions. The intimate cross-connections between the life-cycles of E. pedicellatum, Scytonema, Frullania and their host trees is a very vulnerable system that is difficult to conserve. We are far from understanding the population dynamics of this species and its complex ecological requirements.
Therefore, our present assessment of the status of Erioderma pedicellatum in Newfoundland is that it is a highly threatened species, not so much in terms of its present thallus numbers but largely in consideration of the outstanding vulnerability of this lichen and of its cyanobacterial symbiont towards air pollutants, global warming and clear cutting operations. Much more needs to be learned to fill in the enormous gaps in our current knowledge about the complexity of the life-cycle of E. pedicellatum, upon which the survival of this lichen depends.
Limiting Factors and Threats
- A) Clear Cuts and Tree Plantations
- B) Atmospheric Pollution
- C) Pest Control and the Use of Harmful Aerial Sprays
- D) Forest Fires
- E) Droughts and Hurricanes
- F) Global Warming
- G) Effects of Herbivory on the Growth of Balsam Fir Seedlings
- H) Effects of the Microfauna Herbivory on Erioderma
- I) Land Development
The major threats to the survival of the suboceanic boreal lichen forest habitats of Atlantic Canada and hence to the survival of the cyanophilic lichen communities contained are outlined in the following sub-sections:
Commercial tree harvesting on the Avalon Peninsula and elsewhere in Southern Newfoundland has exceeded the annual quotas set by about 20% and has led to a shortage in forest resources [Data compiled by the senior author for the years 1992-1999: harvested roundwood data taken from Compendium of Forest Statistics for the Council of Forest Ministers (http://nfdp.ccfm.org) and Annual Allowable Cut for insular Newfoundland taken from the Twenty Year Development Plans (1990-2009 and 1996-2015), Department of Forest Resources and Agrifoods].
In many parts of Newfoundland, clear-cutting has led in recent years, since about 1970, to the replacement of many natural to semi-natural forest communities by black spruce and balsam fir plantations. Any of the epiphyte-bearing phorophytes would have been lost during the establishment of clearcuts. The Lobarion community as a whole would not have the capability to regenerate. Even if sufficiently high number of spores of E. pedicellatum were to arrive from distant places, no new thalli could be formed due to the lack of Frullania in tree plantations.
The colonization within established spruce plantations by the above mentioned lichen species and by Frullania is also made difficult by the following factors:
- Under the present environmental conditions, the low buffering capacity and rather strong acidity of black spruce barks make it difficult for E. pedicellatum to become established on the trunks of these trees and even on the branches. Even balsam fir plantations are not colonized by E. pedicellatum or Frullania. The reason for this may have something to do with the death of the original mycorrhizal fungi in clear-cut areas. In contrast, black spruce in natural, more or less well-lit but highly humid Sphagnum-rich forests, is occasionally colonized, although considerable decreases in their populations have been observed in recent years. Trunk occurrences have become virtually non-existent and even on the branches the health of the thalli has deteriorated and their numbers have dwindled along with the regenerative capacity to form juvenile thalli. Two exceptional thalli of E. pedicellatum on the trunks of black spruce next to the Ripple Pond Ridge logging road have remained in healthy condition due to the fact that a steady stream of clear humid air keeps rising from the low-lying wetland immediately to the south during the milder parts of the year. The reasons for these losses lie in the increasing threats from acid fog and acid rain, which seem to affect the chemistry of black spruce bark even under low level impact conditions to such an extent that the barks become unsuitable for colonization by Erioderma. This postulated scenario is supported by the complete absence of E. pedicellatum from otherwise ecologically suitable stands of black spruce in Nova Scotia. Such low level impact of air pollutants seems to have sealed also the fate of this lichen on Norway spruce in Europe.
- The dark shade that exists in recently established tree plantations during the first 10-15 years prior to pre-commercial thinning is not conducive to the reintroduction of viable colonies of Scytonema - enriched Frullania, or to the re-synthesis and development of thalli of E. pedicellatum. Not even traces of Frullania had been found on the barks of black spruce in the plantations to the North of Fundy National Park (Veinotte, 1998 and Maass, personal observations), even though this hepatic commonly occurs in natural woodlands of New Brunswick on both coniferous and deciduous trees.
An added problem is that clear-cuts hardly ever get fertilized leading to the loss of symbiotic mycorrhizal fungi. This could lead to a gradual depletion of nutrients in the thin acidic glacial soils in Newfoundland, Nova Scotia and New Brunswick.
The retardation in the development of the lichen epiphyte floras in tree plantations has been observed and studied in areas to the north of Fundy National Park, as a contribution to an understanding of the Greater Fundy Ecosystem in New Brunswick (Veinotte 1998). Whereas almost all of the four Reference Stands, which were representative of the mature mixed forests in the northern half of Fundy National Park, contained species of Nephroma and Lobaria (almost exclusively on deciduous trees but very exceptionally also on trunks of red spruce (Picea rubens), these cyanophilic species had been absent from all of the black spruces in the 6, 10, 15, 18 and 23 year old plantations studied. Only exceptional thalli of Leptogium cyanescens had been found on an occasional deciduous shrub encountered in the 10 and 15 years old plantations. The latter species is only marginally a component of the Lobarion.
Finally it has been shown that large-scale logging greatly reduces internal stand moisture levels by altering the stand’s ability to buffer periods of desiccation. This is believed to have contributed to the demise of Erioderma pedicellatum in Sweden. As mentioned earlier, one of the original localities in Värmland, Sweden, was designated as a nature reserve in 1952 shortly after a mass occurrence of the species was discovered there by Ahlner in 1941 and 1946 (Ahlner 1948). The presence of logging immediately adjacent to the park boundary and the subsequent desiccation of habitat was one of the suspected causes for the eventual extirpation of the species in this locality (http://www.nhm.uio.no/botanisk/bot-mus/lav/factshts/eriopedi.htm).
It has long been suspected that acid rain eliminates sensitive lichens from suitable ecosystems for two reasons (Hawksworth and Rose, 1976; Richardson, 1992). First the already naturally acidic substrates are further acidified, thereby reducing the buffering capacity of the bark (Nieboer et al., 1984). Second the lichen thallus is immediately affected by the uptake of air pollutants (Farmer et al., 1992). Cyanolichens, in particular, are more vulnerable to the effects of air pollution. All of the cyanophilic lichens are capable of trapping and utilizing molecular nitrogen from the air for the generation of nutrients containing nitrogen. A common characteristic of theirs is that the nitrogen-fixing enzyme, nitrogenase, has a remarkable intolerance for the presence of SO2 (James, 1973).
The presence of acid rain appears to contribute to the loss of Erioderma pedicellatum from its spruce substrates. Even on the slightly less acidic bark of balsam fir, a partial die-back of Erioderma thalli has been observed. The eventual loss of thalli begins with a necrotic zone around the holdfast area and eventually spreads in all directions (Moberg and Holmasen, 1982). Damage to these holdfast zones is pronounced on thalli found on the highly acidic barks of black spruce. The damage to the holdfast areas of Erioderma pedicellatum has been exceptional among the cyanophilic lichens, and therefore is ranked highest on the list for sensitive species of Nova Scotia. In addition, community lichens associated with E. pedicellatum habitats such as the Lobarion are also given a relatively high ranking and have been shown to be sensitive to air pollution (Gauslaa, 1995), including Coccocarpia palmicola, Erioderma mollissimum, Parmeliella parvula and Fuscopannaria ahlneri.
Acid fog is more dangerous than acid rain because sensitive plants remain enveloped in stagnant acid fog for extended periods of time. This could be one of the two determining factors in the gradual disappearance of sensitive cyanophilic lichens from southern Nova Scotia. Acid deposition studies by Cox et al. (1989) in the Bay of Fundy region have shown that the average fog pH was 3.6, i.e., one pH unit lower than the average rain pH in the same area. Although no direct evidence has been shown for the effects of acid fog on lichens, evidence gathered in recent years (Cox et al.1996; Cox et al. 1998; Kouterick et al.1998) indicates that foliar browning in many of the natural stands of heartleaf birch (Betula cordifolia) and white birch in the outskirts of the Bay of Fundy is, either directly or indirectly, caused by acidic fog. Nova Scotia is prone to acid fog since it is closer to the influx of air pollution from the industrial centers of the northeastern U.S.A. and southern Ontario (Maass, 2001). This is in contrast to Newfoundland where the contribution of long range transported air pollution is far less significant than pollution from local sources, including the Come-by-Chance Refinery and the Holyrood Generating Station on the Avalon Peninsula as well as the Pulp and Paper Mills on the West Coast (Wadleigh et al., 1999).
The collapse of the Erioderma pedicellatum - phorophyte connection has probably resulted from the gradual lowering of the buffering capacity of the spruce bark over a period of time, during acid rain or acid fog episodes that would of course simultaneously inhibit the activity of the nitrogenase system. The undernourished hyphae of the holdfast area, after having been deprived of the supply of essential nitrogenous substances (including vitamins), may then become highly susceptible to the presence of SO2 and NOx or to the strong acids derived from them in the stemflow.
In general, it is clear that Erioderma and other lichens possessing the cyanobacterium symbiont Scytonema are highly sensitive to atmospheric pollution. The impact on Erioderma pedicellatum, of the proposed development of a hydrometallurgical plant by INCO at Argentia, using new technology, warrants close monitoring.
The recent threats to the coniferous woodlands and black spruce plantations in the Bay D'Espoir areas around Jipujijkuei Kuespem Park by the Yellow-headed Spruce Sawfly (Pikonema alaskanensis) have been of great concern. As an interim measure, because of BT having been shown to be ineffective in the elimination of the larval stages of this pest, the use of TRICHLORFON (which is known under the trade name "DYLOX") had been approved by the Pest Management Regulatory Agency of Health Canada in 1998 as a spray reagent.
Since the upper cortex of E. pedicellatum does not appear to have significant water repelling properties, its cyanobacterial layer would be readily accessible to aqueous droplets containing this chemical, which could then do damage to the cellular membranes and to the nitrogenase of Scytonema under dry weather conditions. Such a mode of action could seriously decimate the E. pedicellatum populations in the Bay D'Espoir area.
Fortunately, the use of trichlorfon as a spray reagent against the sawflies in Newfoundland has been abandoned for the time being. A far less harmful agent, azadirachtin, an extract from the Indian Neme tree (Azadirachta indica), is currently being used.
Likewise, trichlorfon sprays have not been approved for the Nova Scotia or New Brunswick regions. Instead, efforts are currently underway, in cooperation with the Federal Forestry Service in Fredericton, N.B., to investigate the suitability of specific BT strains (such as BT-i).
It is sometimes difficult to judge whether a particular insect infestation is more harmful to the lichens growing on a tree or the spray reagent that is to be used to reduce the spread of that insect. It probably depends on the extent of the defoliation of the tree and on the annual fluctuations in the population numbers of the insect.
Many areas of Newfoundland have been strongly affected by forest fires. A particularly extensive fire had raged through large tracts of land behind the base of the Burin Peninsula in 1960. This fire may account for the absence of viable E. pedicellatum communities from this general area.
In addition to the obvious impacts of fire, the presence of SO2 in the smoke from burning woodlands is well known and is able to destroy the nitrogen-fixing lichens that happen to be downwind from the burn (see Denison et al. 1976).
Extreme weather induced events, such as drought or windstorms, can affect populations of E. pedicellatum. Prolonged periods of drought may lead to the death of thalli through exposure to heat-induced desiccation. The susceptibility of Erioderma to desiccation may be the result of an upper cortex that appears to lack a vapour barrier in the form of a lipophilic layer of alkanes (see Piervittori et al. 1997). The absence of such a “boundary layer” would promote losses in thallus moisture during dry weather periods (Fos at al. 1999). E. pedicellatum and other lichen populations can also be severely decimated through tree windfalls along the edges of the forests (Boyce, 1988). One such storm had blown across the Avalon Peninsula from a northeasterly direction in November of 1994 and caused considerable wind-fall, in Salmonier Nature Park (SNP), the Lockyer’s Waters Area and on the Ripple Pond Ridge (see NF-62b).
At least one of the original habitats of Erioderma pedicellatum in Nova Scotia was completely destroyed by a windfall when a severe storm traveled from a southwesterly direction and hit the eastern shores of Guysborough County near Wine Harbour (NS-40).
On a macro-scale, the birch die-back in Eastern Canada and in the adjacent parts of the U.S.A. can be viewed as being the immediate result of global warming, according to the work by Auclair (1987) and Auclair et al. (1992). See the explicit review by Braathe (1995). Even though the effects of global warming upon lichens are not as easy to measure as the extent of the birch die-back in Eastern North America (through aerial reconnaissance), they may manifest themselves in having given rise to partial losses of earlier established distributional ranges. In particular, those respective lichens that largely depend on a particular tree species (such as birch) as its main phorophyte, or lichens that are extremely dependent upon high humidity habitats, such as Erioderma pedicellatum, may be sensitive to climate change.
The effects of moose browsing in central Newfoundland have been discussed and evaluated over a period of time by Bergerud and Manuel (1968) and Thompson and Curran (1993). Due to the density of browsing on balsam fir seedlings by moose the mixed coniferous woodlands are gradually being converted into forests in which spruces are the dominant species. The suppression of balsam fir regrowth, based on the current hypothesized life cycle of Erioderma, places limitations on the regeneration of viable E. pedicellatum habitats. There is little doubt that black spruce had once played an important role in providing alternative phorophytes for E. pedicellatum thalli. However, the high acidity of the spruce bark can become in itself a limiting factor to the distribution of E. pedicellatum in Newfoundland, accelerated in the presence of long range transported or locally generated pollutants.
The effect of severe moose browsing on balsam fir is quite evident in Lockyer’s Waters. This could have detrimental effects on the regeneration of young balsam fir stands adjacent to sites containing Erioderma and could therefore inhibit the ability of the formerly large population of more than 953 documented thalli to renew itself through the initiation of new life cycles on nearby trees of suitable age, illumination and environmental health. [According to careful recounts of thallus numbers by Mr. Eugene Conway during the fall of 2002, considerable losses have occurred, leaving only about 20% of the originally counted thalli in place.]
Mites often feed on mosses and on the decaying parts of bark. The effects of browsing by mites on Erioderma thalli are also quite evident in certain field sites although, in general, they do not impose a threat to existing populations of the lichen. Yetman (unpublished data from Masters thesis) has identified at least one species of mite from the Lockyer’s Waters locality that was collected from the surface of a moist Erioderma thallus.
Browsing by snails has also been observed but is a minor threat that occasionally leads to partial removal of the upper cortex and the photobiont layer beneath.
Large-scale mono-cultures also raise the question whether the fungal endo-symbionts in the needles of conifers are naturally introduced. These micro-fungi appear to play an important role in the life of the tree by increasing the resistance of the foliage to attacks by foraging insect larvae (Calhoun et al. 1992, Clark et al. 1989, Todd 1988). The presence of such natural insect feeding deterrents in the needles may not only provide a certain amount of protection against defoliation of the conifers but may also moderate the activities of the micro-fauna on the barks on which the lichens grow.
Road building and the spread of both tourism and industrial activities, such as the harvesting of forests that had not been accessible previously, often go hand in hand. A good example of this had been the building of the Burgeo Road where forest harvesting began soon after the opening of the road. It also opened up the possibilities for conducting a survey of the rare lichens in the area. Unfortunately, what had been gained would soon be lost, which had included the northernmost occurrence of Erioderma pedicellatum on black spruce.
The spread of the cottage industry is similarly taking its toll, mostly in making the more remote parts of the forests more accessible to their utilization. This would include domestic cutting, recreational activities and increased vehicle traffic (Brawn and Ogden, 1977). This is no doubt a legitimate threat in Lockyer’s Waters.
Special Significance of the Species
This “Panda Bear” amongst the lichens (Dr. Teuvo Ahti, in litt.) -- a nickname which E. pedicellatum deserves from the conservation point of view -- is a symbol of nature's rapidly vanishing treasures, in the boreal forest. The complexity of its life cycle, which depends upon the foliose hepatic Frullania as a cyanobacterial donor, is unique among lichens. The species Erioderma pedicellatum has challenged us to improve our understanding of this particular ancient symbiotic life form whose fungal partner is assumed to have evolved through hybridization of two chemically distinct taxa in the north-west corner of South America on the ancient land mass of Gondwana.
The persistence of this lichen throughout hundreds of million years is sharply contrasted by its having been brought to near extinction, within the past 10-20 years, with the notable exception of two core populations from Newfoundland that have remained viable for the time being.
In addition, E. pedicellatum, perhaps more than any other lichen species, can signify changes in local air quality. It has been given the highest rank on the relative scale of sensitivities of cyanophilic lichens towards air pollution, together with species belonging to the genus Lichinodium.
Existing Protection or Other Status
Erioderma pedicellatum had originally been listed in 1995 as critically endangered in the “Red List of Lichenized Fungi of the World”, in the absence of a thorough distribution pattern for eastern North America. This had been determined by the Lichen Specialist Group of the Species Survival Commission (SSC), the International Union for the Conservation of Nature (IUCN).
Even though many of the details upon which the justification for this decision had been based need to be revised and updated, there is still sufficient reason to retain the species on the Red List. For any re-assessment of the status of the species on an international level, it is significant to note that its presence in Europe had been confirmed twice since its presumed disappearance at around 1970 and 1995 (see Distribution).
No official status has been proclaimed yet for the past and present occurrences of Erioderma pedicellatum in any of the three major Atlantic Provinces. Preliminary conservation measures had only been worked out and agreed upon in Newfoundland, in response to suggestions by Dr. Christoph Scheidegger (see Ringius 1997 and Robertson 1998).
For Nova Scotia, the status of E. pedicellatum has become that of a critically endangered lichen. In contrast, E. pedicellatum has remained in apparently viable condition in several parts of Newfoundland, with significant numbers being found in Lockyer’s Waters on the Avalon Peninsula and especially within the boundaries of the Jipujijkuei Kuespem Park in the greater Bay D’Espoir area. These are key areas of known sites that may hold the greatest promise for the longer-term preservation of this species.
Legal protection has existed in Newfoundland for the large population in Jipujijkuei Kuespem Provincial Park as well as for populations in the Bay du Nord Wilderness Area and the Avalon Wilderness Area although these areas were not established specifically to protect this lichen. On the basis of an earlier promise made to Dr. Christoph Scheidegger and the International Committee for the Conservation of Lichens (ICCL) in 1996, by then Premier Brian Tobin, interim protection from logging was also afforded the Lockyer’s Waters Forest Area until the status of this lichen had been determined by COSEWIC.
Summary of Status Report
In total, the number of extant and extirpated localities documented for boreal felt lichen in Canada include about 94 occurrences in about 7 regions of Newfoundland and 46 occurrences from about 4 coastal Atlantic regions of Nova Scotia and 1 locality from New Brunswick. The species no longer exists at the type locality in New Brunswick. In Nova Scotia, it is now known at only 3 of the 46 sites where it was observed formerly. Air pollution rather than loss of habitat is thought to be the main stressor in Nova Scotia. In Newfoundland, where the major concentrations of the species now occur, the senior author has documented losses from such causes as successional changes, logging, major air pollution point source (at Goobies from refinery at Come-by-Chance), possible local air pollution, and biotic impacts (1 major spruce budworm infestation killing balsam fir trees and lichens). The species is now documented from about 50 remaining sites on insular Newfoundland.
Including discoveries in March 2002 in Newfoundland, the total count of documented extant thalli in Canada is about 6900. In view of the many suitable habitats remaining in unexplored remote areas of the southern coast of insular Newfoundland, there are likely as many as twice or more this number, considering the rate of recent discoveries in more accessible areas with increased search effort. The greatest concentrations of thalli currently known are in Jipujijkuei Kuespem Park and in the Lockyer’s Waters area, both in Newfoundland.
For assessment purposes, the mainland populations in Nova Scotia and those of insular Newfoundland have been recognized as distinct COSEWIC populations due to the fact that they occur in different ecological regions and are subject to different degrees of risk, especially from atmospheric pollution [E. Haber, co-chair, SSC Plants and Lichens, COSEWIC].
Range of Occurrence in Canada: Newfoundland
Extent and Area Information
|Extent of occurrence (EO) (km2)||<50 000|
|specify trend (decline, stable, increasing, unknown)||decline|
|Are there extreme fluctuations in EO (> 1 order of magnitude)?||no|
|Area of occupancy (AO) (km2)||<100|
|specify trend (decline, stable, increasing, unknown)||decline|
|are there extreme fluctuations in AO (> 1 order magnitude)?||no|
|number of extant locations||50?|
|specify trend in # locations (decline, stable, increasing, unknown)||decline|
|are there extreme fluctuations in # locations (>1 order of magnitude)?||no|
|habitat trend: specify declining, stable, increasing or unknown trend in area, extent or quality of habitat||decline|
|generation time (average age of parents in the population) (indicate years, months, days, etc.)||30 years|
|number of mature individuals (capable of reproduction) in the Canadian population (or, specify a range of plausible values)||<10 000?|
|total population trend: specify declining, stable, increasing or unknown trend in number of mature individuals||decline|
|if decline, % decline over the last/next 10 years or 3 generations, whichever is greater (or specify if for shorter time period)||?|
|are there extreme fluctuations in number of mature individuals (> 1 order of magnitude)?||no|
|is the total population severely fragmented (most individuals found within small and relatively isolated (geographically or otherwise) populations between which there is little exchange, i.e., < 1 successful migrant / year)?||?|
|list each population and the number of mature individuals in each||too numerous; smallest pop. 1 thallus; largest pop. >1000 thalli; many extirpated in NL|
|specify trend in number of populations (decline, stable, increasing, unknown)||decline|
|are there extreme fluctuations in number of populations (>1 order of magnitude)?||no|
Threats (actual or imminent threats to populations or habitats)
Rescue Effect (immigration from an outside source): unlikely
|does species exist elsewhere (in Canada or outside)?||Nova Scotia|
|status of the outside population(s)?||endangered|
|is immigration known or possible?||?|
|would immigrants be adapted to survive here?||?|
|is there sufficient habitat for immigrants here?||likely|
Range of Occurrence in Canada: Nova Scotia, New Brunswick (extirpated)
Extent and Area Information
|Extent of occurrence (EO) (km2)||<5000|
|specify trend (decline, stable, increasing, unknown)||Decline|
|Are there extreme fluctuations in EO (> 1 order of magnitude)?||No|
|Area of occupancy (AO) (km2)||<20?|
|specify trend (decline, stable, increasing, unknown)||Decline|
|are there extreme fluctuations in AO (> 1 order magnitude)?||No|
|number of extant locations||3|
|specify trend in # locations (decline, stable, increasing, unknown)||Decline|
|are there extreme fluctuations in # locations (>1 order of magnitude)?||No|
|habitat trend: specify declining, stable, increasing or unknown trend in area, extent or quality of habitat||Decline|
|generation time (average age of parents in the population) (indicate years, months, days, etc.)||30 years|
|number of mature individuals (capable of reproduction) in the Canadian population (or, specify a range of plausible values)||<15|
|total population trend: specify declining, stable, increasing or unknown trend in number of mature individuals||decline|
|if decline, % decline over the last/next 10 years or 3 generations, whichever is greater (or specify if for shorter time period)||?|
|are there extreme fluctuations in number of mature individuals (> 1 order of magnitude)?||no|
|is the total population severely fragmented (most individuals found within small and relatively isolated (geographically or otherwise) populations between which there is little exchange, i.e., < 1 successful migrant / year)?||yes|
|list each population and the number of mature individuals in each||NS-12, 1 thallus|
NS-16, 1 thallus
NS-27, 11 thalli
|specify trend in number of populations (decline, stable, increasing, unknown)||decline|
|are there extreme fluctuations in number of populations (>1 order of magnitude)?||no|
Threats (actual or imminent threats to populations or habitats)
Rescue Effect (immigration from an outside source): unlikely
|does species exist elsewhere (in Canada or outside)?||Newfoundland|
|status of the outside population(s)?||special concern|
|is immigration known or possible?||?|
|would immigrants be adapted to survive here?||?|
|is there sufficient habitat for immigrants here?||No|
The senior author wishes to thank the many people and government organizations that have assisted him in various phases of the present work. These include the following:
- Mr. Mac Pitcher, Salmonier Nature Park
- Jon Arne Saeter, a Norwegian nature photographer who took careful field notes during our joint exploration of the Avalon Wilderness in the early part of October 1993, with logistic support being generously supplied by the Parks Authorities.
- Dr. Henry Mann, Grenfell College of Memorial University at Corner Brook, NF, facilitated meetings with Mr. Len Moores of the NF Department of Forest Resources and Agrifoods and Dr. Doyle Wells of the Federal Department of Forestry.
- Mr. Eugene Conway provided field support and connected me with that enthusiastic group of young people who had been employed by the Youth Core Program to study Erioderma pedicellatum and its habitats in Lockyer’s Waters.
- Mr. Bill Clarke at Paddy's Pond and Mr. Joe Brazil, Newfoundland representative of COSEWIC provided updated information on the discoveries of Erioderma pedicellatum in various parts of Newfoundland.
- Chief Michael Joe and his coordinator, Mr. Jerard Joe, of the Conne River Migmaw Band, provided logistic support and encouragement.
- Dr. Christoph Scheidegger of the Swiss Federal Institute for Forestry, Snow and Landscape Research provided me with background information on the European status of Erioderma pedicellatum and on the direction of his own research interests and engagements in describing the population dynamics, life cycle requirements and threats to the survival of this lichen in Lockyer’s Waters.
- Ms. Astri Botnen of the Botanical Institute, University of Bergen, typed up a detailed list of my collections, which enabled me to access the information for the quotation of relevant data on E. pedicellatum.
- Mr. Stephen Clayden, curator of the lichen herbarium at the New Brunswick Museum in Saint John, N.B., examined some of my collections of cyanophilic lichens from Atlantic Canada. His interest in my work and his help in the acquisition of hard to obtain botanical literature on lichen chemistry are gratefully acknowledged.
- Dr. Tomas Hallingbäck supplied me with information on the gradual disappearance of Lobaria species from Southern Sweden, and shared with me his unpublished results on the distribution of cyanobacteria on tree trunks.
- Dr. Gordon Ringius gave permission to make use of his photographs of E. pedicellatum.
- I wish to thank the present owner of Blue Ponds, Mr. Wayne Watton, who had temporarily been in charge of the River of Ponds Park in 1998 and who had treated me to his hospitality.
- Mr. David Yetman shared with me his most recent surveys of Erioderma in Lockyer’s Waters and in the Jipujijkuei Kuespem Park. His detailed data have been most useful in rounding off the existing information on Erioderma for Newfoundland.
- Mr. Trevor Goward of Clearwater, B.C., provided his insights into cyanophilic lichen epiphytes and their significance.
- Dr. Bill Freedman of Dalhousie University, a friend and colleague, was helpful in directing me to publications of interest.
- I wish to thank the Dean of Science at Saint Mary’s University, Dr. David Richardson, and his secretary Mrs. Susan Dorey for their very generous help in the search for important literature and contacts with lichenologists abroad. In particular they provided me with much needed articles published in the Lichenologist and The Bryologist.
- Dr. Peter Wallace of Dalhousie shared his geological knowledge with me and assisted me in finding relevant geological literature.
- I am also grateful to those who have been involved in wordprocessing this report. They include: Miss Heather MacMillan (my son’s enlightened girlfriend and companion); my unselfish neighbour Liana Tessier; as well as Mrs. Tammy Chouinard of the Oceanography Department of Dalhousie University; Mrs. Caroline Baxter and her husband assisted with their computer expertise and helped me with e-mail transmittals of my files.
- During the last stage of my fieldwork in Nova Scotia, I was accompanied by Mr. Bob Guscott of the Nova Scotia Department of Natural Resources.
- I was assisted in my map library work by Mr. James Boxall and Mr. Geoffrey Brown at the Killam Library of Dalhousie University, in determining accurate coordinates for localities visited by myself and those appearing in reports issued by the NDFR at Paddy’s Pond.
- As a former employee of the National Research Council of Canada, I received unlimited library services from CISTI through the kind assistance of Mrs. Anna Backman and Mr. Ian Young, librarians at the Institute for Marine Biosciences of the National Research Council in Halifax, N.S.
- Financial assistance for the preparation of this status report was provided by the Canadian Wildlife Service, Environment Canada and the Newfoundland Department of Forest Resources and Agrifoods. In addition, some of my fieldwork was financed through a grant from the Voisey’s Bay Nickel Company through Youth Services Canada. The same source also supplied financial and logistic support for fieldwork in the Jipujijkuei Kuespem Park and in other parts of the Bay D'Espoir area.
[including annotated comments in some cases]
Ahlner, S. 1948. Utbredningstyper bland Nordiska Barrträdslavar (i.e. Distributional Patterns for Fennoscandinavian Lichens growing on Coniferous Trees). - Uppsala. Almquist & Wiksells Boktryckeri AB. - Doctoral Thesis which contains a description of Erioderma boreale Ahlner n.sp. and where its relationships to some of the South American species of Erioderma are outlined.
Ahti, T. 1983. Chapter 8. Lichens. pp. 319-360 In Biogeography and Ecology of the Island of Newfoundland. Edited by G.R. South. Dr. W. Junk Publishers. Den Hague.
Ahti, T. and P.M. Jørgensen. 1971. Notes on the Lichens of Newfoundland. I. Erioderma boreale, New to North America. - The Bryologist 74: 378-381.
Asakawa, Y., J.C. Muller, G. Ourisson, J. Foussereau and G. Ducombs.1976. Nouvelles lactones sesquiterpenique de Frullania (Hepaticae). - Bull. Soc. Chim. Fr. 1456-1466.
Auclair, A.N.D. 1987. The Climate Change Theory of Forest Decline. - IUFRO Conference on Woody Plant Growth in a Changing Physical and Chemical Environment, Vancouver. Environment Canada, 29 pp.
Auclair, A.N.D., R.C. Worrest, D. Lachance and H.C. Martin. 1992. Climatic Perturbation as a General Mechanism of Forest Dieback. - Pages 38-58 In Forest Decline Concepts, edited by P.D. Manion and D. Lachance. The American Phytopathological Society, St. Paul, Minnesota.
Bajzac, D. and B.A. Roberts. 1996. Development of Ecological Land Classification and Mapping in Support of Forest Management in Northern Newfoundland, Canada. - Environmental Monitoring and Assessment Vol. 39: 99-213.
Benedetto, J.L. T.M. Sánchez, M.G. Carrera, E.D. Brassa and M.J. Salas. 1999. Palaeontological constraints on successive paleogeographic positions of precordillera terrane during the Early Paleozoic. Geological Society of America Special Paper 336, pp. 21-42.
Bergerud, A.T. and F. Manuel. 1968. Moose Damage to Balsam Fir - White Birch Forests in Central Newfoundland. - J. Wildlife Management 32: 729-746.
Bergerud, A.T., F. Manuel and H. Whalen. 1968. The Harvest Reduction by a Moose Population in Newfoundland. - J. Wildlife Management 32: 722-728.
Boyce, R.L. 1988. Wind Direction and Fir Wave Travel. - Can. J. For. Res. 18: 461-466.
Braathe, P. 1995. Birch Dieback - Caused by Prolonged Early Spring Thaws and Subsequent Frost. - Norwegian Journal of Agricultural Sciences. Supplement No. 20 (59 pages). - Norwegian Forest Research Institute, Ås, Norway.
Brawn, K. and J.G. Ogden III. 1977. Lichen Diversity and Abundance as Affected by Traffic Volume in an Urban Environment. - Urban Ecology 2: 235-244.
Burnett, W.C., S.B. Jones, T.J. Mabry and W.G. Padolina. 1974. Sesquiterpene lactones - Insect Feeding Deterrents in Vernonia. - Biochem. System. Ecol. 2: 25‑29.
Calhoun, L.A., L.A. Calhoun, J.A. Findlay, J.D. Miller and N.J. Whitney. 1992. Metabolites Toxic to Spruce Budworm from Balsam Fir Needle Endophytes. Mycol. Res. 96(4): 281-286.
Christmas, M. 1980. Ascospore Discharge and Germination in Xanthoria parietina. - Lichenologist 12: 403-406.
Clark, C.L.,J.D. Miller and N.J. Whitney. 1989. Toxicity of Conifer Needle Endophytes to Spruce Budworm. - Mycol. Res. 93(4): 508-512.
Clayden, S.R. 1997a. Campobello to Avalon: A Lichen Saga. - N.B. Naturalist 24(2): 72-74.
Clayden, S.R. 1997b. Seasonal Variation in Ascospore Discharge by Rhizocarpon lecanorinum. - The Lichenologist 29: 495-499.
Connolly, J.D., A.A. Freer, K.Kalb and S.Huneck. 1984. Eriodermin, a Dichlorodepsidone from the Lichen Erioderma physcioides - Crystal Structure Analysis. - Phytochemistry 23(4): 857-858.
Cox, R.M., K.B. Kouterick, J.E. Hurley, J.W. Malcolm, J.M. Skelly and S.P. Pennypacker. 1998. Fundy Fogs: Their Changing Chemistry and Impacts on Two Birch Species. - Conference on Fog and Fog Collection, Vancouver, Canada, 19‑24 July 1998.
Cox, R.M., G. Lemieux and M. Lodin. 1996. The Assessment and Condition of Fundy White Birches in relation to Ambient Exposure to Acid Marine Fogs. - Can J. For. Res. 26: 682-688.
Cox, R.M., J. Spavold-Tims and R.N. Hughes.1989. Acid Fog and Ozone: Their Possible Role in Birch Deterioration around the Bay of Fundy, Canada. - Water, Air, and Soil Pollution 48: 263-276.
Crandall-Stotler, B., R.E. Stotler and P. Geissler.1987. A Biosystematic Study of the Subspecies of Frullania tamarisci (L.). - The Bryologist 90(4): 287-308. - Shows profiles of flavanoids, sesquiterpene lactones and dissimilar protein banding patterns of the phosphoglucoisomerases. The chemical diversity of biologically active flavonoids (i.e., flavone and isoflavone glycosides) and sesquiterpene lactones in these hepatics may have provided an ideal environment for the establishment and growth of the early symbiotic stages in the life cycle of Erioderma pedicellatum, according to ideas expressed by W. Maass.
Crum, H.A. and L.E. Anderson. 1981. Mosses of Eastern North America. Columbia University Press, N.Y. - States that Leucodon sciuroides reported by Tuomikoski et al. (1973) from Newfoundland is Leucodon brachypus var. andrewsianus (which may be encountered in some of the habitats of Erioderma).
Delaney, B.B. and M. Cahill. 1976. A Pattern of Forest Types on Ribbed Moraines in Eastern Newfoundland. Can. J. For. Res. 8: 116-120.
Denison, R., B. Caldwell, B. Bormann, L. Eldred, C. Swanberg and S. Anderson. 1976. The effects of acid rain on nitrogen fixation in Western Washington conifereous forests. U.S. Dept. Agric. For. Serv. Gen. Tech. Rep. NE-23. In, Proc. 1st Int. Symp. Acid Precip. For. Ecosystems 933-949.
Directoratet for Naturforvaltning. 1994. Kystgranskogen i Midt-Norge. - Tungasletta 2 - 7005 Trondheim. - On page 2 are two colour photographs taken by Jon Arne Saeter in the Salmonier Nature Park in October of 1993, one being Erioderma pedicellatum on the trunk of an Abies balsamea, and the other being the corresponding habitat photograph entitled “Boreal Rain Forest in Canada”.
Elix, J.A., D.O. Chester, K.L. Gaul, J.L. Parker, and J.H. Wardlaw. 1989. The Identification and Synthesis of Further Lichen β-Orcinol para-Depsides. - Aust. J. Chem. 42: 1191-1199. - Includes methyl 5-chloronorobtusatate, a mixed depside with an orcinol type of ring B from an unidentified species of Erioderma in the Azuay District of Ecuador (on the road the between Gualaceo and General Plaza at 3100 m alt.; leg. Arvidsson and Nilson # 1722, GB). The species is most probably a hybrid which had been formed from suitable parents (including E. wrightii !) in relatively recent times (i.e. after the formation of the Andes).
Elix, J.A., J.E. Evans, and T.H. Nash. 1988. New Depsides from Dimelaena Lichens. - Aust. J. Chem. 41: 1789-1796. - Includes the chemical synthesis of wrightiin and other 3-chloro derivatives of orcinol based depsides. The presence of wrightiin and of an accompanying un-identified constituent (which is most probably identical with conwrightiin) has been confirmed in a specimen of Erioderma wrightii from Ecuador.
Elix, J.A., U.A. Jenie, L. Arvidsson, P.M. Jørgensen, and P.W. James. 1986. New Depsidones from the Lichen Genus Erioderma. - Aust. J. Chem. 39: 719-722. - Describes the Extraction of pannarin related β-orcinol depsidones from the “Chemical Race of E. chilense from the Azores” and their separation by HPLC.
Elix, J.A., I. Mahadevan, J.H. Wardlaw, L. Arvidsson, and P.M. Jørgensen. 1987. New Depsides from Erioderma Lichens. - Aust. J. Chem. 40: 1581-1590. - β-Orcinol type of depsides in an unidentified species from Loja Province in Ecuador (6 km South from Saraguru, collected at 3000 m alt. by L. Arvidsson and D. Nilson under # 2134, GB) which include methyl 4-O-demethylbarbatate and its 5-chloro derivative (which are the non-aldehydic equivalents to the cortical depsides atranorin and chloratranorin) as well as five fully substituted metabolites of the methyl Eriodermate series. - This species is a good candidate for having been the donor of genes for the formation of aromatic ring A in the mixed depside methyl 5-chloronorobtusatate (see comments under reference for Elix et al. 1989). The latter metabolite occurs in an apparent cross between this species and Erioderma wrightii.
Farmer, A.M., J.F. Bates and J.N.B. Bell. 1992. Chapter 11. Ecophysiological Effects of Acid Rain on Bryophytes and Lichens, pp. 284-313. In: Bryophytes and Lichens in a Changing Environment, ed. by J.W. Bates and A.M. Farmer. Clarendon Press, Oxford.
Fos, S., V.I. Deltoro, A. Calatayud, and E. Barreno. 1999. Changes in Water Economy in Relation to Anatomical and Morphological Characteristics During Thallus Development in Parmelia acetabulum. - Lichenologist 31(4): 375-387. - Shows that young thalli have a very limited water holding capacity and that they are not as yet in possession of a fully functional lipophilic boundary layer in the upper cortex which would delay the evapo-transpiration of water during dry weather periods.
Galloway, D.J. and P.M. Jørgensen. 1987. Studies in the Lichen Family Pannariaceae II. The Genus Leioderma Nyl. - Lichenologist 19(4): 345-400.
Gauslaa, Y. 1985. The Ecology of Lobarion pulmonariae and Parmelion caperatae in Quercus Dominated Forests in South-West Norway. - Lichenologist 17(2): 117‑140.
Gauslaa, Y. 1995. The Lobarion, an Epiphylic Community of Ancient Forests Threatened by Acid Rain. - Lichenologist 27(1): 59-76.
Gowan, S.P. and I.M. Brodo. 1988. The Lichens of Fundy National Park, New Brunswick, Canada. - The Bryologist 91: 225-325.
Hawksworth, D.L. and F. Rose.1970. Qualitative Scale for Estimating Sulphur Dioxide Air Pollution in England and Wales using Epiphytic Lichens. - Nature (London) 227: 145-148.
Hawksworth, D.L. and F. Rose. 1976. Lichens as Pollution Monitors. - Studies in Biology No.66. - London: Edward Arnold.
Holien, H., G. Gaarder and A. Håpnes. 1995. Erioderma pedicellatum Still Present but Highly Endangered in Europe. - Graphis Scripta 7: 79-84.
Holien, H. and Tønsberg. 1996. Boreal regnskog i Norge - habitatet for trøndelagselementets lavarter. - Blyttia 54 (4): 157-177.
James, P.W. 1973. The Effects of Air Pollutants, other than Hydrogen Fluoride and Sulfur Dioxide on Lichens in Air Pollution and Lichens. - Athlone Press of the University of London, London, pp. 143-175.
James, P.W. 1982. Lichens and Air Pollution. A booklet to accompany the wall chart published by The British Museum of Natural History, B.P. Educational Services, pp. 1-29. - Detailed description of the Zone Scale for the estimation of mean sulphur dioxide levels in England and Wales (adapted from Hawksworth and Rose in Nature, London 227: 145-148); with good descriptions and drawings.
Jørgensen, P.M. 1972. Erioderma pedicellatum (=E. boreale) in New Brunswick, Canada. - The Bryologist 75: 369-371. - This refers to Hue’s publication on Solorina in which the description of the lichen Pannaria pedicellata (the basionym of E. pedicellatum) had been included.
Jørgensen, P.M. 1990. Trøndelav (Erioderma pedicellatum) - Norges mest gatefulle plante ? Blyttia 48: 119-123. - Is referring to the origin of the genus Erioderma in Gondwana Land.
Jørgensen, P.M. 2001. The present status of the names applicable to species and infraspecific taxa of Erioderma (lichenized ascomycetes) included in Zahlbruckner’s Catalogus. Taxon 50: 525-541.
Jørgensen, P.M. and D.J. Galloway 1989. Studies in the Lichen Family Panariaceae III. The Genus Fuscoderma, with Additional Notes and a Revised Key to Leioderma. - Lichenologist 21(4): 295-301.
Kouterick, K.B., J.M. Skelly, S.P. Pennypacker and R.M. Cox. 1998. - Acidic Fog and Septoria betulae Pass. Impacts on Two Birch Species along the Bay of Fundy, Canada. - Conference on Fog and Fog Collection. Vancouver, Canada, 19-24 July 1998.
Lamb, I.M. 1954. Lichens of Cape Breton Island, Nova Scotia. - National Museum of Canada Bulletin. No. 132 pp. 239-313.
Maass, W.S.G. 1980a. Lichens as biological Indicators of Pollution. In: Proc. Symposium on Environmental Studies in Jamaica, University of the West Indies, Mona, May 25 and 26, 1979.
Maass, W.S.G. 1980b. Erioderma pedicellatum in North America: A Case Study of a Rare and Endangered Lichen. - Proc. N.S. Inst. Sci. 30: 69-87.
Maass, W.S.G. 1983. New Observations on Erioderma in North America. - Nordic J. Bot. 3: 567-575.
Maass, W.S.G. 1991. Unpublished Distributional Maps of Rare Lichens in the Cape Chignecto area, based upon surveys between 1982 and 1991. Prepared for the NS Department of Natural Resources.
Maass, W.S.G. (in preparation for 2003a). Effects of Long Range Transported Industrial Air Pollution upon Cyanophilic Lichen Epiphytes and their Phorophytes along a Gradient Between the New England Mountains and Newfoundland. - Presented as a lecture at the LICONS meeting held in Birmensdorf near Zürich, Switzerland, in the early part of September 1999. See Abstracts for International Conference on Lichen Conservation Biology, Licons, 30.8.-3.9.1999 Birmensdorf.
Maass, W.S.G. (In preparation for 2003b). A Hypothetical Outline of Palaeozoic Migrations of the Lichen Genera Leioderma and Erioderma and of the Environmental Conditions that may have been Responsible for the Biochemical Evolution of Erioderma, of other Ancient Genera of Lichens and of Symbiotic or Free-living Fungi from Geologically Unstable Marine Environments. - To be submitted to “Symbiosis” for publication. - Will contain an update on the formation
of the hybrid species E. pedicellatum in the northern parts of South America and on its adventurous journeys from there into the Northern Hemisphere.
Maass, W.S.G. and A.F. Hanson. 1986. Wrightiin, a new Chlorinated Depside from Erioderma wrightii Tuck. (Ascolichenes). - Zeitschr. f. Naturforsch. 41-b: 1589‑1592.
Maass, W.S.G. and D.H.S. Richardson. 1994. Report to Nova Scotia Power Inc. on “A Natural Vegetation Baseline Study involving Lichens and Sphagnum Mosses as Bioindicators” as part of the Air Effects Monitoring Program around the Point Aconi Generating Station (Unit No 1). 69 pp.
McHugh, Sherry. 1998. A study on the endangered lichen Erioderma pedicellatum in Lockyer’s Waters, Newfoundland. Youth Services Canada Project. Newfoundland.
Moberg, R. and I. Holmåsen. 1982. Lavar. En fälthandbok - Interpublishing, Stockholm. - Contains photographic evidence of air pollution damage to thalli of Erioderma pedicellatum and to the branch on which they had been growing.
Nieboer, E., J.D. McFarlane and D.H.S. Richardson. 1984. Modification of Plant Cell Buffering Capacities by Gaseous Air Pollutants in Koziol, M., and F.R. Whatley (eds.), Gaseous Air Pollutants and Plant Metabolites, Butterworths, London, pp. 313-333.
Norwegian Forestry Journal Statskog. 1995 Nr.1. Contains an excellent colour photograph of the second last thallus of Erioderma pedicellatum encountered in Norway. The photograph had been taken by Jon-Arne Saeter in 1994.
Piervittori, R., L. Usai, F. Alessio and M. Maffei. 1997. The Effect of Simulated Acid Rain on Surface Morphology and n-Alkane Composition of Pseudevernia furfuracea. - Lichenologist 29(2): 191-198.
Quilhot, W., B. Didyk, V. Gambaro and J.A. Gabarino. 1983. Studies on Chilean Lichens VI. Depsidones from Erioderma chilense. - J. Nat. Prod. 46: 942-943.
Richardson, D.H.S. 1992. Pollution Monitoring with Lichens. Naturalists’ Handbook: 19. Richmond Publishing Co. Ltd., P.O. Box 963, Slough, SL2 3RS, England.
Ringius, Gordon. 1997. Evaluation of potential impacts of development on Erioderma pedicellatum in Eastern Newfoundland. Canadian Forest Services Review.
Robertson, A. 1998. The Boreal Felt Lichen (Erioderma pedicellatum (Hue) P.M. Jørg.) in Newfoundland. Geographical Distribution and Dynamics of its Habitats in Forested Landscapes. Prepared for Government of Newfoundland and Labrador, Department of Forest Resources and Agrifoods, Forestry, Wildlife and Inland Fish Branch.
Scheidegger, C. 1996. Copy of letter sent by Dr. C. Scheidegger to the Right Honourable Brian Tobin, Prime Minister of NF, dated October 30, 1996. - The letter is containing his ideas about the complex reproductive strategies of Erioderma, about the limited life span of its thalli, and about its life cycles being intimately tied to certain ecological stages in the growth of coniferous trees within a more or less undisturbed forest environment.
Thompson, I.D. and W.J. Curran. 1993. A Reexamination of Moose Damage to Balsam Fir-White Birch Forests in Central Newfoundland: 27 Years Later. - Can. J. For. Res. 23: 1388-1395.
Todd, D. 1988. The Effects of Host Genotype, Growth Rate, and Needle Age on the Distribution of a Mutualistic, Endophytic Fungus in Douglas Fir Plantations. - Can. J. For. Res. 18: 601-605.
Tønsberg, T. 1993. Additions to the Lichen Flora of North America. - The Bryologist 96: 138-141.
Tuomikoski, R.,T. Koponen and T. Ahti. 1973. The Mosses of the Island of Newfoundland. - Ann. Bot. Fennici 10: 217-264. - Regarding the report of the moss Leucodon for Newfoundland.
Veinotte, C.A. 1998. A Comparative Analysis of Plant Communities in Natural, Mixed-Species Forests and Silvicultural Plantations within the Greater Fundy Ecosystem, New Brunswick. Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master in Science. Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia. September 1998.
Wadleigh, M.A. and D.M. Blake. 1999. Tracing Sources of Atmospheric Sulphur Using Epiphytic Lichens. - Environmental Pollution 106: 265-271.
Wolseley, P.A. 1995. A Global Perspective on the Status of Lichens and their Conservation. - Mitt. Eidgenöss. Forschungsanstalt für Wald, Schnee und Landschaft 70: 11-27.
Yetman, D., 1999. The Health and Population Viability of Erioderma pedicellatum ((Hue) P.M. Jørg.) in Jipujijkuei Kuespem Provincial Park and the Proposed Lockyer’s Waters Ecological Reserve. A report submitted under contract to Parks and Natural Areas by David Yetman, B.A., B.Sc.
Wolfgang S.G. Maass was born on 23 October 1929 in Helsinki/Finland to a German father and a Swedish Finnish mother and went to Primary School both in Finland and Germany and to Highschool in Greifswald on the Baltic Sea. For two years he studied Botany and Chemistry at the Ernst-Moritz-Arndt University in Greifswald (East Germany) and then at the Eberhard Karl’s University in Tübingen (West Germany). He was fortunate in having had outstanding teachers in biochemistry and plant physiology, Professor Adolph Butenandt (who had received the Nobel Prize in chemistry for his work on testosterone and who later became the Director of the Max Planck Gesellschaft) and Professor Erwin Bünning (the re-discoverer of the biological clock). He obtained his doctoral degree (Dr.rer.nat.) in 1957, based on a thesis entitled “Light growth reactions and Phototropism in Phycomyces blakesleanus”. For half a year he was employed as a Research Assistant in the Botanical Institute of the University of Tübingen. From 1958-1960 he worked at the Max Planck Institut für Eiweiss -und Lederforschung on the chemistry of tannins in Norway spruce (Picea abies) and isolated the stilben glucoside “piceatannol” from its needles. This compound had previously been shown to be present in the bark where the aglycone was held responsible for the formation of tannins.
Through having taken part in one of Professor Bünning’s traditional field trips to Torne Lappmark and in field trips with Professor Helmut Gams to Lule Lappmark and the Monte del Vesuvio near Naples, he had been introduced to the Floras of the Arctic and of the Mediterranean. He had also been commissioned to make a contribution to the “Kleine Kryptogamenflora von Helmut Gams” by supplying a key to the identification of Sphagnum mosses.
In 1960 he applied for a Postdoctoral Fellowship, got married to Regine Bürgener and emigrated to Canada. For about half a year he worked at Dalhousie University with Professor Kraft von Maltzahn on gametophyte cultures of Sphagnum and tissue cultures from the cambium of Norway spruce but these projects were abandoned after Professor von Maltzahn had left for Europe on his sabbatical leave. He then went to work as a guest researcher in the “Atlantic Regional Laboratory” of the N.R.C. with Jim Craigie on ion exchange in peatmosses and on the distribution of peatmosses in Atlantic Canada.
After his having been offered a staff position at the same Institution he began to work, under the inspiring influences of the late Dr. Arthur Neish and Dr. Neil Towers, on the biosynthesis and chemistry of lichen substances. In 1971-1972 he had been on an outside staff posting in Munich to learn enzymological techniques at the Max-Planck-Institut für Zellchemie under Professor F. Lynen. Unfortunately, work on the pulvinic acid synthetase in Pseudocyphellaria crocata and in Letharia vulpina ran into unsurmountable difficulties because of interferences by the large amounts of metabolites in these lichens. It would be necessary to grow large batches of mycobiont cultures under controlled conditions before activating the pulvinic acid synthetase for the isolation of the enzyme. In 1975 he published the first 2-directional thin layer chromatography system for the separation of lichen acids - a technique which was subsequently refined by the Culbersons at Duke University (see Can. J. Bot. 1975 and J. Chrom. 1976, 1979 and 1981). During his years with N.R.C., he had begun to conduct surveys of the lichen flora of Atlantic Canada, especially after the presence of Erioderma pedicellatum in North America had become known (Ahti and Jørgensen 1971, Jørgensen 1972). Subsequent work had led him to investigate the type locality of E pedicellatum and to conduct several expeditions to Newfoundland and the adjacent coast of Labrador.
In 1986 he took early retirement but continued fieldwork in the Maritime Provinces. As a Research Associate of Dalhousie University, he participated in surveys and research on the watershed chemistry of southern Nova Scotia and on the Thread-leaved Sundew Drosera filiformis, as well as on the Model Forest Project in and adjacent to the Fundy National Park. In addition, he was given a contract by the Nova Scotia Power Corporation to make use of lichens and peatmosses as potential biomonitors of atmospheric pollution around the newly constructed Point Aconi Power Plant. A letter of agreement by COSEWIC had been awarded to him in 1996 and had kept him busy until now.
Information on the chemistry of Erioderma and on the biochemical evolution of the species has been provided by the senior author, who is also responsible for the distributional maps, the growth measurements of young rapidly expanding thalle, for the bark acidity measurements and the water retention capacities for even-aged barks of balsam fir and black spruce .
David Jason Yetman was born in Red Bay Labrador on November 26, 1973. He received a Bachelor of Arts in Psychology from Carleton University of Ottawa in June 1995 and a Bachelor of Science with Honours, in Biology from Memorial University of Newfoundland in May 2000. He received an NSERC research scholarship in 1999 to complete a Masters degree on the genetic variability of Erioderma pedicellatum within Newfoundland and between extirpated Swedish populations. The research was carried out both in Newfoundland and Switzerland, at the Swiss Federal Research Institute. All the data have been collected and a draft of the Masters thesis is near completion. Currently David is the executive director of the Labrador Straits Development Corporation where he is working on several environmental research projects.
- Date Modified: